Hegenbart 14
Christine, Research Assistant at the Academy for Politics and Current Affairs of the Hanns Seidel Foundation in Munich. She was a PfP Fellow at the Research Division at the NATO Defense College in the spring of 2013. “Semantics Matter NATO, Cyberspace and Future Threats.” NATO Defense College (2014). https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep10385
All in all, the use of cyber weapons is especially problematic and is a very serious issue. Currently most states, and also NATO as a military alliance, focus on defending against cyber threats. This strategic orientation raises concerns about the ethical and legal implications of using cyber tools. But an increasing number of nation states see cyber capabilities as important instruments, and as weapons to be used in interstate conflicts. However, military and political decision-makers will have to pay close attention to the circumstances under which it is beneficial to use cyber weapons outside the ‘classic’ theater of military operations. There is the danger of miscalculating the result of cyber-attacks, thereby escalating the conflict and triggering retaliation outside cyberspace with conventional armaments.
Apart from these six types of cyber conflict, the term cyber-attack deserves particular notice. The word takes on a variety of meanings, according to the specific security fields. A precise and narrow definition would help de-escalate the rhetoric. In order to reduce confusion and uncertainty in a military context, the term cyber-attack should only be used to describe cyber conflicts with a military dimension. Their effects have to be significantly damaging: either disruptive (i.e. drastic, obvious and immediate) or corruptive (i.e. subtle and persistent).30 Consequently, only instances of cyber sabotage, cyber terrorism and cyber war(fare) should be identified as cyber-attacks.
It is important to define, especially for NATO, what constitutes the use of force through cyber technology. The Tallinn Manual on the International Law Applicable to Cyber Warfare, launched by NATO’s CCDCOE is not an Alliance directive, but provides guidance on the matter. It defines a militarily relevant cyber-attack as “a cyber operation, whether offensive or defensive, that is reasonably expected to cause injury or death to persons or damage or destruction to objects.”31 The definition is shaped by the result: if a cyber operation is followed by significant destructive consequences, it qualifies both as a cyber-attack and as use of force. If hostile cyber activity leads only to inconvenience or irritation, it is neither a cyber-attack nor the use of force. The fundamental understandings of this term have to be discussed because, in the end, the evaluation will be a political decision.