Stanley-Lockman & Trabucco 3/22
Zoe Stanley-Lockman & Lena Trabucco , “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs”, Zoe Stanley-Lockman Nanyang Technological University, Lena Trabucco University of Copenhagen, Center for Military Studies The Oxford Handbook of AI Governance Edited by Justin Bullock, Yu-Che Chen, Johannes Himmelreich, Valerie M. Hudson, Anton Korinek, Matthew Young , and Baobao Zhang Subject: Political Science, Political Institutions Online Publication Date: Mar 2022DOI: 10.1093/oxfordhb/9780197579329.013.69 – ECM
AI Governance and Military Affairs: Tensions in Existing Literature
Academic literature has long grappled with the intersection of emerging technology and security organizations.13 Two branches of literature that tackle core questions of technological trajectories and its relationship to human and social structures—a critical question of governance for military technology—are STS studies and military innovation scholarship. Although the theoretical approaches in STS and military innovation studies differ, they both share the important assumption that technology does not have its own innate logic, and instead measure technological change by its impact on social structures and interactions with humans. In other words, both fields treat technology as an enabler in broader structures. The term technology is ubiquitous enough that it does not have a single definition, but it is often defined in relation to human intention and purpose. Alex Roland describes technology as a “purposeful human manipulation of the material world” to “serve some human purpose.”14 If extending this basic idea of technology to technological innovation, then both STS studies and military-innovation scholarship lend relevant criteria.
Both academic fields are also relevant because, in the policy space, AI governance stakeholders are pursuing responsible research and innovation (RRI), which comes from STS studies, and defense stakeholders are similarly focused on responsible innovation and responsible use. More traditionally, the direct study of military adoption of technology is considered in the separate scholarship of military innovation, which includes a school of thought that focus on cultural and organizational factors. Between these two fields, an interdisciplinary approach is helpful here to carry STS approaches to AI governance, including RRI, over to the space of military innovation.
However, this is complicated by the reality that military organizations that see technological superiority as a core element of deterrence and defense, including NATO, engage in forms of technological determinism that STS scholars squarely reject. Respective views on technological determinism—which considers that technology shapes society as a largely autonomous process with limited human agency—thus creates a tension for governance prospects.15 To spotlight the aspects of military innovation related to governance, this section briefly expands on the overlaps and tensions between STS and military innovation literature.
Science, technology, and society (STS) studies
STS studies is helpful to understand how technologies such as AI develop relative to the human, social, and political structures that shape it, rather than as an independent entity to which humans have to adapt.16 In this vein, AI is not just a computational process involving software, hardware, and data,17 so much it is a socio-technical system that encompasses “human, social, and organizational factors.”18 Together, these factors enable a focus on the trajectory of technological development relative to social structures and power dynamics. STS scholars have also helped develop RRI frameworks that seek to guide technological development in anticipatory, participatory, and adaptive frameworks to achieve desirable outcomes and prevent undesirable ones.19 RRI is a structured approach to innovation in which stakeholders identify and act on their “collective commitment of care for the future through responsive stewardship of science and innovation in the present.”20 It drives civilian AI ecosystems for NATO Allies that will also indirectly affect NATO.21