Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The thesis of the da turns case – other countries will develop new weapons regardless of international norms – that only makes the US’s position worse

Yoo 17

(John, Emanuel S. Heller Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law; Visiting Scholar, American Enterprise Institute, “Embracing the Machines: Rationalist War and New Weapons Technologies”, California Law Review, Vol. 105, Issue 2) DB

Cyberweapons and drones do not yet appear to bear these characteristics. The marginal gains in deploying these weapons will not be even across nations, but instead may be asymmetric. Some nations will experience much greater gains in military capability by developing cyber and drone technology. Or put differently, prohibition or regulation of these new weapons will not have equal impacts on rival nations. Chinese military doctrine, for example, emphasizes using such technologies to offset U.S. advantages in conventional sea and air power. 116 Drones might be used to overwhelm the defenses for U.S. carrier groups in the Western Pacific, while cyber weapons could interfere with U.S. command-and-control, communications, or even military readiness. Just as the Germans resorted to submarines to offset British and American naval superiority in World Wars I and II, the Chinese may well turn to robotics and network attacks in a future contest. Reciprocity will not hold because international limitations on new weapons would have the effect of favoring the United States’ existing advantage in conventional arms.

Even if there might be some mutual advantage to a universal limit on these new weapons technologies, it is still doubtful that nations would accept a legal agreement. Nations would still develop these weapons because they improve their military capabilities at lower cost. Aerial drones, for example, can achieve the objective of attacking an enemy target at lower cost. An F-35 Lightning II stealth fighter/bomber costs $85 million under the best estimates, while Predator and Reaper drones cost about $4 million and $16.9 million respectively.117 The U.S. Air Force can not only purchase twenty Predators for the cost of a single F-35, but it can operate them at a far lower cost per hour, keep them on station for far longer (a predator can fly over a target area for up to fourteen hours) but also not risk the lives of pilots who may be captured or killed.118 Militaries will have an incentive to replace expensive manned aircraft with fleets of drones, regardless of whether their rivals choose to match them or not.

Cyber and robotic weapons today resemble the emergence of the new weapons borne of the industrial age. At the time of their emergence, the impact of high-capacity firearms, long-range artillery, warplanes, submarines, and motorized vehicles was not well understood. World War I’s carnage can be attributed to the failure of nineteenth century tactics and strategy, still influenced by Napoleonic theories, to adapt to the greater firepower of modern weapons. Although nations and experts proposed the regulation of aerial and submarine warfare, their asymmetric benefits and the uncertainty of their effects on the balance of power precluded any agreement among the combatants. Nations may prove even more reluctant to adopt arms control schemes for weapons that have strong defensive qualities, such as the machine gun and artillery, because upgrading defensive systems may pose little offensive threat to neighbors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.