Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

We outweigh on magnitude – wars using new AI weapons prevent conventional weapons, which are worse

Yoo 17

(John, Emanuel S. Heller Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law; Visiting Scholar, American Enterprise Institute, “Embracing the Machines: Rationalist War and New Weapons Technologies”, California Law Review, Vol. 105, Issue 2) DB

Such mistaken arguments confuse jus in bello and jus ad bellum. The means of fighting a war do not bear on the justifications for the war. A war that rests on just grounds need not be fought in an evenhanded fashion. One might want a war that has a just purpose to come to a quick and rapid conclusion, with the least loss of life as possible, which should be more likely if one side has a great advantage over the other. Again, the Kosovo War provides a good example. If we agree with the goal of stopping Serbia’s ethnic cleansing of the provinces of the former Yugoslavia, we should want NATO to execute the war with the maximum dispatch and effectiveness. A faster war, fought with precision weapons and reduced combat casualties, could end the human rights catastrophe earlier and save more lives. Similarly, if a nation were defending itself, we should want it to have the most advanced weapons possible. Superiority itself may not just deter an attack; it could also inflict such high costs in an actual war that the attacker may give up.

In fact, the critics of autonomous systems support a rule that could just as well produce more death and destruction. Preemptively banning such advanced weapons systems would establish a technological parity among many nations. We could witness wars that grind on for years between nations with similarly matched weaponry and tactics. The world witnessed such a conflict a century ago in the trench warfare of World War I. Even World War II, which favored offensive weaponry and tactics, lasted for six years and killed millions more than the Great War. Technological discoveries, such as the atomic bomb, shortened the war and saved millions of lives. If today’s human rights advocates had persuaded Roosevelt, Truman, and Churchill to preemptively ban nuclear weapons research, the invasion of Japan would have taken an estimated one million Allied lives and eight to nine million Japanese.136 Of course, we would not have wanted Nazi Germany or Imperial Japan to develop advanced weapons first, but that merely confirms that whether we want nations to enjoy superiority in war depends on whether we agree with why those nations employ force.

The real-world consequences of military technology point to a rejection of a categorical ban on new weapons. As with drones, autonomous weapons systems no doubt often allow nations at war to wage hostilities with greater lethality for the enemy, but at a lower cost to their soldiers. A weapon’s improved effectiveness in cost-benefit terms should not prompt efforts at bans; rather, they should be welcomed for reducing the destructiveness of war. Technology that makes war more effective by making targeting more precise, reducing combatant and civilian deaths, and ultimately shortening conflicts will improve overall global welfare, a result that any system of rules on war should seek.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.