It makes conflicts more peaceful – regulating weapons fails
Yoo 17
(John, Emanuel S. Heller Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley, School of Law; Visiting Scholar, American Enterprise Institute, “Embracing the Machines: Rationalist War and New Weapons Technologies”, California Law Review, Vol. 105, Issue 2) DB
A rationalist approach to war also provides an answer to the broader critique of the new weapons technologies as facilitating war. Recall that some UN officials and scholars share the concern that drones and cyberweapons will encourage states to wage war more often. Critics argue that these weapons remove a nation’s soldiers from the battlefield, thereby emboldening leaders to choose force more frequently. But, understanding war as a bargaining failure reveals the importance of signaling to resolving international disputes. New weapons create more opportunities for signaling, which allows nations to communicate their intentions and capabilities more effectively. Greater signaling should allow nations to share more information, which on the margins will lead to more international deals and therefore an overall reduction of major wars. Ironically, an effort to ban new weapons may well produce more war, not less.
CONCLUSION
The rise of robotics and cyberwarfare has blurred our understanding of what constitutes “war.” Indeed, within weeks, both blanketed American news media. First, according to news reports, the Central Intelligence Agency concluded that Russia had attempted to influence the 2016 presidential elections by hacking into the computer systems of the Democratic National Committee and the campaign of candidate Hillary Clinton. Then, China captured a U.S. submersible drone in the South China Sea, in violation of international legal right of free navigation. Perhaps few see these actions as “war,” in the traditional sense. And yet, many would feel differently if Russian spies entered the United States to tamper with election result or if Chinese marines had boarded an American warship. These examples, however, only begin to introduce the complexity of robotics and cyberwarfare, because they involve powerful and identifiable state actors. When nonstate groups adopt these measures, understanding “war” seems less and less feasible.
The technology that has created aerial drones will produce unmanned versions of many other weapon systems, from tanks to submarines to sentries. Criticism of this advance misses the mark. Rather than an unknown to be feared, new weapons technology will bring a greater precision in the use of force that will reduce casualties and destruction. Allowing the use of robotic weapons against a broader range of targets promises to contain the harm of international disputes and help lead to peaceful settlements. Concerns about autonomous weapons are equally mistaken. Such systems promise to increase the precision and decrease the harms of attack. In a world beset by fresh challenges to international security, reducing the costs and increasing the accuracy of force may reduce the obstacles to action to stop weapons of mass destruction proliferation, terrorist groups, humanitarian disasters, or revanchist powers.