AI coop doesn’t undermine US innovation
Lawrence and Cordey 20
(Christie and Sean, “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence”, ) DB
The Case for Transatlantic Cooperation
There are three critical, interconnected arguments for transatlantic cooperation to ensure AI innovation protects the security, values, and economic interests of the United States and the European Union.
1.Global Good: Transatlantic AI partnerships and cooperation encourages innovation and applications that enhance human welfare, strengthen the economies of the US and the EU, and advance global security.
2.Great Power Competition: US-EU leadership of like-minded nations is needed in this age of great power competition to tip the scales against efforts by authoritarian governments—particularly, China and Russia—to undermine democracies.
3.Shared Values: The US and the EU share fundamental values and would benefit from joint efforts to establish AI norms that would more effectively advance their common vision of AI and ripple throughout the global AI ecosystem.
Although the US consistently sounds the alarm bells around China’s AI aspirations and the EU urges international efforts against AI that violates fundamental rights, increasingly noting China’s actions with concern,8 little concrete international action has taken place. The United States and the European Union’s ongoing reassessment of their respective AI strategies and legislation9 provides a window of opportunity to align and collaborate. Transatlantic AI cooperation is at a critical juncture and the United States and the European Union should seize this opportunity to take concrete actions.
The Current State
The United States and the European Union are separately assessing and updating their AI strategies. However, it is a myth to assume they are not collaborating at all to advance their AI-related goals. Transatlantic cooperation on AI norms, standards, research and development, and data sharing should increase, but the United States and the European Union can build upon an existing foundation for a stronger alliance.
United States:The United States views American leadership in AI as necessary to safeguard American values and maintain defense and economic superiority. Recognizing the need to develop a national AI approach and reclaim the AI R&D global leadership position from China, which had already surpassed the US in several research output metrics by 2016,10 the Obama Administration developed an AI R&D prioritization in October 2016.11 Building on this urgency, the Trump Administration has prioritized AI and established the American AI Initiative in February 2019.12 This Initiative identified the need for a whole-of-government approach to prioritize AI R&D and deployment throughout the entire federal government. The Initiative also identifies the need to grow the US AI workforce, set national and global norms and standards, and work with industry and allies to promote an AI environment favorable to the United States.13
The United States’ federal government has made key strategic and tactical changes to achieve these goals. Federal AI R&D and the American AI Initiative are coordinated by several committees and subcommittees within the Executive Office. President Trump pledged to more than double non-defense AI R&D to $2 billion by 2022.14 Federal AI R&D, guided by the National AI R&D Strategic Plan, must now be reported annually for each federal entity.15 The United States has taken a “light-touch” approach to regulation, fearing overly burdensome laws will stifle innovation. However, guidance is not completely absent. The Office of Management and Budget released a memo to guide Federal agencies as they develop regulatory and non-regulatory approaches to non-government applications of AI and the Department of Defense published five AI principles to guide AI design, deployment, and adoptions in defense.16
Obstacles to the US realizing its goal of global AI leadership exist, despite the government’s prioritization of it. Key obstacles include the need to bolster its private sector AI landscape; address regulatory or standards gaps to safeguard American values; repair the breakdown of funding and information sharing relationships between academia, industry, and government; grow its AI workforce; and further increase its federal AI R&D funding.
European Union: The European Union, like the United States, intends to leverage AI’s potential as a strategic and transformative technology.17 However, the EU has positioned itself as a leader in trustworthy, human-centric, ethical, and values-based AI,18 in comparison to the US government’s emphasis on the need for AI innovation to protect American values, civil liberties, and privacy. The EU recognizes that it trails behind the US and China in terms of volume of investment and maturity of its tech industry.19 Nonetheless, the EU believes it can capitalize on its underlying structural strengths (e.g., academic and innovation record) and on its values to compete globally and reaffirm its digital and technological sovereignty.20 Starting with its 2018 Communication: Artificial Intelligence for Europe,21, 22 the European Commission (EC) has launched a coordinated effort promoting AI.23 Policies include increasing public and private investments from $5.6 billion to $22 billion annually;24 coordinating research and innovation across Europe; devising ethical guidelines; fostering digital skills in its workforce; and promoting public and private sector adoption of AI.25 To support and counsel these efforts, the EC has established the High-Level Expert Group on AI (AI HLEG) comprising 52 experts who advise the Commission on policy and regulatory changes.
The European Union’s Juncker26 Commission (2014-2019) actively avoided regulating AI, causing the European Parliament to increase their efforts as a proactive voice in favor of stronger AI regulation. However, since the beginning of Ursula von der Leyen’s tenure, the Commission has initiated efforts to adopt stronger regulation for AI applications (i.e., differentiating regulation of AI based on defined “high-risk” and “low-risk” sectors”) and associated data spaces.27,28 These legislative proposals and their associated discussions are planned to be completed by the end of 2020. During the strategic planning and budgeting process of its R&D programs, the EU committed to providing at least EUR10.7 billion29 for AI-related research conducted between 2021 and 2027.30 Despite these financial and political efforts, the EU still remains technologically dependent on the US and China and suffers from a lack of capital and private funding, decentralized and uncoordinated AI expertise, severe brain drain (including to the US), and slow adoption of AI programming in its education and public sectors.
Transatlantic Cooperation: Despite over 40 years of scientific relationships and projects between the United States and the European Union, AI-specific collaboration has been fraught with varying degrees of political and academic skepticism on both side of the Atlantic, notably within the European Commission and the governments of some Member States (e.g., France and Germany).31 Such a dynamic is aggravated, in part, by the ever-deteriorating transatlantic relationship spurred by policy and trade disagreements, public spats, and increasing American isolationism. Despite such explicit omissions and stand-offs at the highest levels, transatlantic collaboration for AI does happen, most notably in various multilateral forums working on standards (e.g., ISO, IEC, IEEE, G7, G20) or on ethics and norms (e.g., OECD, GPAI32).33 In recent months, however, interests and political support for greater transatlantic coordination on AI seems to be increasing. This trend was notably demonstrated by a visit from Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan—then Director of the US Department of Defense’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC)—to Brussels in January 2020 and a visit by the European Parliament’s delegation to Washington D.C in February 2020. Both visits included discussions on AI with a variety of key stakeholders, such as NATO, representatives from the US Congress, State Department, Federal Transit Administration (FTA), Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB).34
Transatlantic collaboration for AI-related research is taking place at varying levels although these projects are relatively ad hoc and materialize within existing scientific and technological research agreements and roadmaps. For instance, the current Roadmap for US-EU Science & Technology prioritizes four areas for transatlantic cooperation, most of which leverage AI (e.g., health, transportation, bioeconomy, marine and arctic research) or promote institutions that do (e.g., European Organization for Nuclear Research or CERN).35, 36 These collaborative links are supported and promoted through a variety of arrangements and initiatives, such as BILAT 4.0, EURAXES37 or the European Network of Research and Innovation Centers and Hubs (ENRICH). In general, and despite challenges to systematically integrating US entities into European research programs, the US remains the leading non-EU (“third country”) participant in Horizon 2020,38 with over 60 participations and 1,200 partnerships.39 US funding contributions to Horizon 2020 and participation in AI-related projects, however, is meager than its broader research involvement in Horizon 2020. For instance, US collaborative links with Horizon 2020 projects can only be found in 2% of AI-related projects, 12% of deep learning projects, and 4% of machine learning-related projects.40 Accordingly, there is still plenty of room for improvement.41