Brands 2020
[Hal, Bloomberg Opinion columnist, the Henry Kissinger Distinguished Professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies, and a scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, “If America and China Go to War, It Won’t Be an Accident,” Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-08-07/war-between-china-and-america-won-t-happen-by-accident]
This isn’t the same thing as saying that a Chinese-American war won't happen. Conflict tends to occur when one party decides that war, or actions risking war, is preferable to living with the status quo or backing down in a crisis. That could happen all too easily. If China concludes that Taiwan is distancing itself too far from the mainland politically, as the balance of power shifts in Beijing's favor militarily, then it might decide that war is better than letting the dream of reunification slip away. If Chinese leaders worry that their domestic legitimacy is slipping, they might behave more belligerently in a crisis, for fear that war is less dangerous than humiliation. Beijing might even gamble that the U.S. would stay out of a short, sharp war with Japan over the Senkaku Islands or the Philippines over Scarborough Shoal, and that gamble might not pay off. But in any of these cases, Beijing would be making a deliberate choice to seek key objectives through the use of coercion or force, with the knowledge that a larger conflict is a real possibility. If a U.S.-China war results from such a choice, it could hardly be called an accident. Why does this matter? Because it bears on the best way of avoiding war in the Pacific. Establishing memorandums of understanding on how military forces operating in close proximity should conduct themselves, creating mechanisms for communication in a crisis, and other steps to encourage de-escalation is helpful. What is critical, however, is maintaining the military balance of power, and the perception of U.S. commitment, that makes it less likely that Chinese leaders could imagine a war in the region going their way. That is a huge and urgent task. It involves not just spending money but devising operational concepts and new capabilities, such as autonomous systems and artificial intelligence, that make it prohibitively difficult for China to project power. It requires strengthening U.S. alliances that have atrophied or been damaged during the administration of President Donald Trump. That agenda may seem daunting, given how badly the situation in the Western Pacific has eroded. Yet Americans shouldn't fool themselves into thinking that just managing crises and mitigating misperception — as important as those objectives are — offer a cheaper way to preserve the peace.