Cyberwar is merely a manifestation of capitalism – automating war against the working class. Refuse the aff’s project as a continuation of the neoliberal war machine. It’s try or die for the alternative’s movements to abolish the order altogether.
Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19 (Nick, associate professor @ University of Western Ontario in Faculty of Information and Media Studies, Svitlana, assistant professor of communication @ Simon Fraser University, “What is to be done?”, Chapter 3, Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism)
The argument of this book is that cyberwar is a manifestation of the competitive nature of capitalism, which, beneath the surface of globalization, fosters a war of all against all, conducted in the accelerated, automated, and abstracted forms on which this entire mode of production now depends. It follows from this that the prospects for reducing the dangers of cyberwar, and of the other types of war of which it is now part, depend strongly on movements and struggles to constrain and, ultimately, abolish this internally antagonistic order. A recognition of the extreme difficulty of this project is inherent in the point on which we opened this chapter, namely, Noys’s observation that the military high-technology “endocolonization” of society has been a factor in decomposing the traditional industrial working-class movements that were historically the main agencies of socialist and communist projects. However, there is also a possible reversal of this logic, if averting war, including cyberwar, becomes entwined with other issues, such as struggles for social equality and ecological sustainability, a focal point for recomposition of movements looking beyond capital, drawing on new and diverse constituencies. We have indicated some of the issues that we think might be drawn together around resistance to the rise of cyberwar: antisurveillance sentiment, rejection of the secrecy of the security state and its new digital complexes, concern over the corruption of the general intellect by mis- and disinformation, objection to corporate and military criminality, and, of course, revulsion at the exterminatory horrors of war, from the terror of dirty wars to global thermonuclear catastrophe.
In his reflections on Marxist theories of war and revolution, Balibar (2002) remarks on the coexistence within this body of thought of two contradictory elements, one stressing the idea of “revolutionary war,” the other of “revolutionary peace.” The first stresses “armed struggle against capital,” the second “the refusal of capitalist wars”—“in many respects this class war is therefore also a non-war, or an anti-war” (11). If, in the title to this chapter, we invoked Lenin’s What Is to Be Done?, it is partly to remember that, though Lenin is today primarily thought of as a theorist of revolutionary war, perhaps the major decision of Leninism was one for peace (even if his later adoption of Trotsky’s formula of “no war, no peace” resonates with today’s state of cyberwar). The outbreak of World War I precipitated a schism in the international socialist movement. Leading European socialist democratic parties all too rapidly discarded their longheld view that war exemplified the irrationality of competitive capitalism, forgot their commitments to peace and worldwide worker solidarity, rallied behind their governments, and joined the march to mass slaughter. Only the faction of what is sometimes known as the Zimmerwald Left (Nation 1989), led by Lenin, continued to speak out for internationalism. It was thus not just revolt against exploitation but rejection of the holocaust of World War I, a program of “bread and peace,” that gave communism a moral claim to universality. Terrifying contemporary parallels to the pre1914 years today demand an updated strategy for “bread and peace,” with “bread” understood as a securing of ecological conditions for species life and “peace” as elimination of systemic social violence.
One of the slogans of the Zimmerwald Left was “Krieg dem Krieg,” “war on war,” and it is tempting to take this up, in a very literal sense, and propose a “cyberwar on cyberwar.” As we have seen, there is a hacking front to both the struggles against digital militarism and contemporary anticapitalist movements. They have exposed the workings of the cyberwar complex and brought it to light. Their main figures are defectors from that complex. More broadly, over recent decades, many critical theorists have argued for forms of “cyborg” dissent and for deployment of the arms available to “immaterial labor,” whether in the networked mobilization of protest or in more direct digital disruptions of war making. Cyberwar on cyberwar is both a metaphorical and practical possibility, and we have seen situations when “Krieg dem Krieg,” in the most concrete sense, is the only effective response to murderous attack.