Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Pedagogy is key and shapes subjectivity – debate is a cite for alternative education that refuses capital – the permutation is co-option and an example of how white, male, heteronormative educational institutions are designed to consume radical scholarship and twist it in the service of capital

Hall 21 –Professor of Education and Technology at De Montfort University, Director of the Institute for Research in Criminology, Community, Education and Social Justice. He is also a member of the Centre for Urban Research on Austerity and a Research Associate in the Centre for Computing and Social Responsibility at DMU, PhD, MA [Richard, “Alternative Education,” Critical reflections on the language of neoliberalism in education: dangerous words and discourses of possibility, Routledge, 2021, DKP]

Alternative education raises questions about whether another world is possible. Alternatives ask educators and students to question the governance, regulation and resourcing of hegemonic, institutionalized forms of education, alongside their curricula, through prefigurative practices. The idea of an alternative questions the legitimacy of formalized spaces, often standing against both their forms and content, and as a result defining an educational undercommons (Harney & Moten, 2013). Such an undercommons is a space for solidarity and resistance, from where resources and relations can be drawn. It might exist inside formal education, as a sector of the economy or in its institutional forms. An undercommons forms an underground that enables subversion and new forms of organization, and which problematizes dominant narratives about education (for entrepreneurship, growth, sustainable development and so on).

In this being inside-and-against the school or the university, alternative education takes the perspective of voices that are marginalized because they are racialized, gendered or rendered economically valueless or indebted, in order to re-imagine and re-produce new forms of educational life or sociability. The idea of an alternative also emerges beyond formalized spaces, in autonomous communities that exist beyond the school or university as it is repurposed as a factory (Cleaver, 2002; University of Utopia, The, n.d.).

This idea of alternatives being in, against and beyond recognizes that hegemonic educational institutions have been subsumed within the circuits of capital. This means that the governance and forms of such institutions, and the work of academics, professional service staff and students, have been reengineered by capital on a global terrain. Moreover, the labor that takes place inside these institutions is repurposed and re-produced in its relation to money capital, productive capital and commodity capital, in order to generate surplus value, surpluses, profits and so on. The domination of capitalist social relations over academic labor is driven by the abstracted power of money and the generation of surplus value. This opens up the possibility for alternative forms of education, both inside formal spaces and beyond the boundary of the formal, to become new sites of struggle in response to the on-going crisis of sociability. This crisis is signalled by the co-option of socially useful knowledge, or the general intellect, so that it can be valorized (Hall, 2018; Virno, 2004). Educational relationships have been productively intensified in order to facilitate the expansion of capital, rather than for the solution of global, socio-economic and socio-environmental crises. Inside the school or the university, educational innovations are fetishized as emancipatory, whereas in working against and beyond these spaces, scholars in alternative educational spaces are working to abolish the relations of production that drive societies to ignore concrete emergencies (Hall & Smyth, 2016).

From inside-and-against the hegemonic institution, alternatives articulate the limits of formal education, including its problematic nature as a public or private good (Marginson, 2012). Here, the idea of the school or university as a form of enclosure of knowledge and practice is refused through public intellectualism or educational activity that is conducted in public. Such activities widen debates over ideas and fields of study beyond the academy to the public, in that they refuse both the colonization of disciplinary spaces by academics and the delegitimation of certain voices. This public activity contains the germ of militancy (Neary, 2012; Thorburn, 2012) because it aims to do counter-hegemony and be counter-hegemonic. As a form of workers’ enquiry, militancy in research or pedagogic practice points toward projects that produce knowledge useful for activist ends. This may take the form of open education or scholarship that refuses neoliberal recuperation (Eve, 2014) for the production of marketized outcomes like performance data, or new spaces for the generation of surpluses or profits. Such refusals question the societal value of business-as-usual models for public, higher education (Open Library of Humanities, 2020).

However, experiments that are against hegemonic practices also offer the potential for radical experiment, alongside the re-imagining of education as a distributed, co-operative, democratic activity. Such experiments question education’s relationship to society. Prefigurative responses then emerge in the pedagogic practices of social movements rooted in pedagogy (Caldart & the Movement of Landless Workers, 2011), and through forms of resistance inside the university grounded in community and environmental justice (Pearce, 2012), resistance to gender-based violence, and trades union educational activity (Scandrett, 2014). This work situates the experience of the educator and student against that which emerges from within social movements, in order to address the possibilities for alternative forms of knowing and being. Here traditions of critical pedagogy are central to the ways in which critical knowing and being emerge to challenge the dominant framing of learning, teaching and scholarship as separate from society and everyday life (Amsler, 2015; Motta and Cole, 2016).

Work that emerges beyond formal educational contexts is situated in practical, alternative initiatives that point toward alternative, societal re-imaginings of education. Such re-imaginings are forms of autoethnography, framed by the idea of the student or educator as a co-operative activist, and as such operating collectively through organic intellectualism (People’s Political Economy, 2013; Social Science Centre, The, 2016). Such alternatives offer a means of using critical sociology and critical pedagogy to analyse concrete moments of crisis of specific communities, such as the politics of austerity and climate justice (Buxton & Hayes, 2015; Lockyer & Veteto, 2013).

In particular, these alternatives are infused by comparative analyses with the pedagogic practices of indigenous communities and people of colour (Motta, 2016; Zibechi, 2012), for whom the crisis of sociability imposed by capitalism is on-going, historical and material. Such practices are affirmative in attempting to generate new cultural definitions and recognitions (Connell, 1987), as acts of becoming (Braidotti, 2011). Here, the white, male, heteronormative educational institution is the adversary of and antithetical to an ongoing process of becoming. In its deployment of organizational forms, technologies and institutional spaces, pedagogic practices and assessment regimes, it seeks to maintain the domination of the market. As such, in order to move beyond the market as the sole arbiter of crises, it becomes important to nurture alternative educational spaces that are affirmative of intersectional lines of flight away from our hegemonic anchoring points (Braidotti, 2011; Yuval-Davis, 2006). A key issue is whether those voices which catalysed or contributed to crisis, are the same voices who should dominate our responses.

Such affirmative lines of flight develop analyses that specifically relate cooperative, inclusive educational practices of creating and legitimizing communities, and challenge the on-going colonization of knowing and being. They offer ways to refuse the dominant power relations of knowledge production inside contemporary capitalism, and instead speak of decolonization by feminized and racialized subjects on the margins. This enables those projects to establish unique analyses of educational possibility from within new, emancipatory horizons. These analyses recognize the desire for progressive and democratic forms of education: first, in terms of its governance and politics, and the social relations that circulate inside educational spaces; and second, in terms of enacting radical pedagogies grounded in the abolition of power relations in the classroom.

Here a re-politicization of autonomy becomes central to a movement away from the internalization of capitalism’s value-set, which is rooted in productivity/intensity and where any alternative mode of life is seen as sinful. Tactical and affective autonomy reduces the acceptance of hierarchical discipline, and increases demands for the quality and content of work that is both necessary/in the sphere of heteronomy and free/in the sphere of autonomy (Gorz, 1982). What alternative education offers is less a masculine, engineered, corporate life driven by technique, and instead one rooted in humane values where individuals rather than capital are sovereign. Anything otherwise makes capital/exploitation/appropriation central to a productive life, and diminishes the space for a useful life.

Marx (1894/1991) describes the sphere of freedom or autonomy beginning beyond the sphere of necessity or heteronomy. Freedom consists of being able to work with as much dignity and efficiency as possible (in the sphere of necessity) for as brief a time as possible. It is important that a heteronomous sphere is subordinate to the sphere of autonomy, with the maximum efficiency and the least expenditure of effort and resources. The key is to make it possible for individuals to move from heteronomous, wage-based social labor effected in the general interest and requiring little time or intense involvement, to autonomous activities which carry their end in themselves. This resonates with descriptions and discussions of self-actualization through the classroom, rooted in acts of teaching that “share in the intellectual and spiritual growth of our students” (bell hooks, 1994, p. 13). Moreover, it takes alternative educational spaces as pivots for reimagining the curriculum for two reasons. First, because by dismantling the curriculum, we are able to reveal flows of alienation at the intersections of: self/subject and other/object reflected in it; gender and race reproduced through it; and the disciplinary separations demanded by it. Second, we are able to re-describe the curriculum as a form of social wealth and a process of struggle (Ahmed, 2012; Olufemi, 2017).

From this complex educational ecosystem, alternatives sit against the neoliberal enclosure of existing structures and forms, like the school and university. They stress: first, democratic activity, based upon a radical politics; second, militant research strategies, which see research as a tool for political action and for widening the field of struggle against the re-production of alienating forms of education; third, the re-definition of scholarship undertaken in public, as a revolutionary activity. In a politics of community engagement and cross-disciplinary activity, and in radical education collectives, these strategies form cycles of struggle that point toward possibilities for: detonating the school or university (Amsler & Neary, 2012); using prefigurative pedagogical practices that enable labor to become the crisis of capital, so that it might become for itself rather than being for capitalization or valorization (Holloway, 2002; Occupied California, 2010); and describing what society might become (School for Designing a Society, The, 2016)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.