Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative solves. The role of debaters as academics is to reject the proliferation of securitized cyberwar discourse in the capitalist unconscious.

Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19 (Nick, associate professor @ University of Western Ontario in Faculty of Information and Media Studies, Svitlana, assistant professor of communication @ Simon Fraser University, “What is to be done?”, Chapter 3, Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism)

As both of us are academics, we are concerned with how the neoliberal university is occupied today by cyberwar. Responding to the exhortations of states and corporations for a supply of labor power adequate to cyberwar conditions, institutions of postsecondary education are proliferating cybersecurity programs (Talley 2013; Ritchie 2016; Wilson 2017). They are also the target of intensifying cyberattacks, some aimed at military-related research (Ismail 2017; Young and Bennett 2017). But, most immediately from our point of view, the university has become a place where students receive mutually contradictory messages from faculty teaching critical theory about the risks of state and corporate surveillance and the public relations teams hired by higher administrators that encourage them to “like” the university’s profile on Facebook, follow it on Twitter, and become full participants in a regime of corporate promotion and selfbranding. Not only does this jeopardize pedagogical work (except when one manages to use such instances as case studies for politicoeconomic analysis in class, which is admittedly rare) but it is also unethical given the general awareness (including by higher administrators and public relations teams) that youths are being aggressively targeted by corporate platforms. This targeting does not just leave young people feeling stressed, defeated, overwhelmed, anxious, nervous, stupid, silly, useless, and like a failure. It also prepares them as the unthinking data-subject cannon fodder for wars already being waged with computational propaganda, botnets, and the viral relay of virtual weaponry with real material consequence.

We and our students are subjects of the “capitalist unconscious,” “the alienated subject at work in every discursive action” (Tomšič 2015, 54). Lacan traced the notion of the subject to the beginning of modern science, which initiated the emancipation of the human from theocratic social orders, replacing a ritualistic relation to the world of nature. Unfortunately, as Samo Tomšič argues, “the emancipatory political potential of scientific revolution” was captured and “neutralized” by a counterrevolutionary capitalism that “needs to be thought of as the restoration of pre-modernity within modernity” (235). This neutralization he characterizes as the construction of “a closed world, marked by totality, finitude and centralization”—the world market, mobilizing atomized, narcissistic, and competitive individuals in never-ending and all-subsuming commodity exchange, a world whose purported eternity and completion negate the perception of “contingency, infinity and instability” that is the true core of scientific emancipation. Pointing to a parallelism between Marx and Lacan, Tomšič observes that capitalist modernity “ceases at the critical point of the subject” (235). He explains,

While capitalism considers the subject to be nothing more than a narcissistic animal, Marxism and psychoanalysis reveal that the subject of revolutionary politics is an alienated animal, which, in its most intimate interior, includes its other. This inclusion is the main feature of a non-narcissistic love and consequently of a social link that is not rooted in self-love. (233)

The atavistic “pre-modernity within modernity” of capitalism, and the disaster of its capture of advanced science, is nowhere more clearly demonstrated today than by its tendencies toward cyberwar. As the young Althusser (1946, 14) wrote in the midst of the “apocalyptic panic” following the explosion of the first atomic weapons, “the world in which humanity trembles before what it has itself wrought is an extravagant image of the proletarian condition, in which the worker is enslaved by his own labour: it is quite simply, the same world.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.