Increased US action in disease mitigation is critical to NATO effectiveness
Giovanna De Maio 2020. Was a nonresident fellow in the Center on the United States and Europe at Brookings. She is currently a visiting fellow with George Washington University’s Institute for European, Russian, and Eurasian Studies. “NATO’S RESPONSE TO COVID-19: LESSONS FOR RESILIENCE AND READINESS.” Brookings. October 2020. https://www.brookings.edu/research/natos-response-to-covid-19-lessons-for-resilience-and-readiness/#:~:text=In%20spite%20of%20this%2C%20NATO,health%20crisis%20from%20impacting%20readiness. IZP)
COVID-19 has been a systemic wake-up call, exposing vulnerabilities in health, international cooperation, and the global economy. NATO showed reliability and solidarity under the initiative of its civil and military personnel amid COVID-19. Yet, one could only imagine how easier and more efficient NATO’s response would have been if the alliance did not have to overcome tense political issues between member states and if NATO’s stronger member, the United States, had adopted a more cooperative approach78 to the virus response both internationally and domestically, similarly to what had been done for Ebola in 2014.79 This could not only have helped the NATO Public Diplomacy Division’s outreach in pushing back against disinformation, but also used the resources of the organization — constantly targeted in Trump’s complaints because of its financial burden — to share costs and responsibilities and ultimately reassure partners and markets. Instead, from a political perspective, the global pandemic revealed that American leadership can no longer be taken for granted.80 Trump not only denied the gravity of the virus, but also imposed travel bans without coordinating with European allies, abdicated leadership of the G-7 which the United States was chairing,81 withdrew from the World Health Organization,82 and refused to join international efforts to produce a vaccine.83 This behavior will leave significant scars in the trans- Atlantic partnership, of which NATO is the main pillar, and has pushed Europeans to talk more concretely about increasing their own defense capabilities.84 In spite of its respectable performance during COVID-19, one might be tempted to argue that there is not a lot to be optimistic about when it comes to NATO’s future, given widespread fatigue with multilateralism, political tensions within and between member states, and a global economic recession. With GDP plummeting worldwide, policymakers and public opinion may be reluctant to support an increase in defense spending. Because of shrinking economies, the 2% of GDP commitment for NATO members will, ironically, be easier to achieve, in the very short term. However, once GDP recovers to earlier levels there may be significant downward pressure on defense budgets throughout the alliance. Yet, in the short to medium term it is reasonable to worry about defense sector supply chains and how this will impact NATO’s fighting capabilities.85 It is therefore of paramount importance that the alliance rethink the defense spending requirement, adapting it to new technological challenges which entail not only more cost-effective options but also a broader concept of security that encompasses protection of supply chains, infrastructure, and humanitarian operations. Although disruptive, COVID-19 will not be the main factor that influences the future of NATO, which has survived sharper political divergences between its members in the past, like on the U.S.- led Iraq War in 2003. With major challenges ahead, including nuclear deterrence, Chinese and Russian geopolitical ambitions, terrorism, and increased migration flows, it is critical for NATO allies to build a common vision. As Stoltenberg recently remarked,86 the alliance needs to become “more global,” and to do so it is paramount for the U.S. and Europe to develop a common stance towards China, increase efforts to fight terrorism, and make defense more sustainable in the future. While the COVID-19 crisis will hopefully be overcome with a vaccine and NATO will benefit from this experience to increase its resilience towards future challenges, the future of the alliance itself depends on the trust between the allies. In this regard, the outcome of the U.S. election will have a major impact on the alliance itself and on its focus, and will determine either a relaunch of the trans-Atlantic cooperation on strategic infrastructure, environmental security, and deterrence against outside powers, or an historical retrenchment occurs that leaves it up to Europeans to take the lead in one way or another.