Adversaries are engaged in hybrid warfare now that compromises decisionmaking – risks escalation
Lucarelli et al 2021 - Professor at the University of Bologna, member of the Board of Directors of the Forum on the Problems of Peace and War and of the Institute of International Affairs
Sonia Lucarelli Alessandro Marrone Francesco N. Moro “Executive Summary” Nato Decision-Making In The Age Of Big Data And Artificial Intelligence, Nato Allied Command Transformation Università Di Bologna Istituto Affari Internazionali
Digital revolution has substantially transformed the world we live in, providing great opportunities but also making societies more vulnerable. Technology makes external interferences cheaper, faster and all- encompassing: citizens can potentially become direct targets of information warfare, all members of a society can be part of conflicts one way or another. From advanced weaponry to command and control, most security-related domains are undergoing deep transformations as data availability and transmission increase exponentially. In this context, three interconnected aspects are explore through this publication with a view to the Alliance’s evolution: Big Data and organizational challenges for NATO; hybrid threats to Allies’ decision- making; the adoption of AI in the defense domain and NATO’s role.¶ Big Data and Organizational Challenges for NATO. Basing decisions on a much larger amount of information than was previously possible could lead to a real revolution in the decision-making processes of complex organizations, especially because this information would concern different dimensions of reality and it would be constantly updated. Beside the huge quantity of information available, the high speed at which the data are generated and need to be processed is another defining factor of Big Data. Also, they will typically be acquired from diverse sources and their trustworthiness has to be carefully evaluated. Finally, any data can have different value in different phases of the decision-making process. All these features impose specific requirements on organizations that aim at using Big Data to reduce the uncertainty in which they operate. For instance, the huge volume of data compels to acquire new data storage technologies, while the high speed demands new processing tools and the variable trustworthiness and value force organizations to elaborate new methods of analysis. Accordingly, any actor that seeks to exploit Big Data should have clear goals and a well-defined strategy to delineate and implement its specific objectives.¶ A key issue with Big Data is providing decision makers with data that are truly relevant for their purposes, and not simply interesting. Chief data officers and senior data-related leadership positions will acquire a crucial importance in the analysis of information and in the actual decision-making process, but these positions require a special mix of talent and tools that are currently scarce in many large organizations, especially in the public sector and even more in the military one.¶ Another key issue lies in the emerging tension between centralization and decentralization of the decision- making process of organizations that are introducing Big Data analysis in their work. Paradoxically, while Big Data should promote widespread responsibility and tactical awareness, at the moment advanced digitalization seems to be linked to clear centripetal forces in large organizations. The centripetal tendency leads towards the de-responsibilization of the lower ranks and to a progressive loss of practice in choosing. Thus, it would be advisable to integrate Big Data in the Alliance’s decision-making favoring diffused ownership and devising different tools for different branches of the organization, based on their specificities. It would also be helpful to create well-designed and reliable evaluation procedures to measure the effectiveness of organizational innovations as well as of the execution of the new decision-making processes. In particular, identifying the initial failures is especially important, to learn from them and avoid structural problems.¶ Hybrid Threats to Allies’ Decision-Making. Hybrid threats is a broad category encompassing a variety of actors, actions and targets. As for actors, due to their actual capabilities, intentions and recent track records, China and Russia can be identified as the most gathering threats.¶ Concerning actions, information is key under several respects. It refers to Big Data and AI taken together, as the latter entails the use of algorithms to learn from the former with a view to exploit the target’s vulnerabilities. Digital connections are the underlying infrastructure used to perpetrate hybrid threats in the information domain. Western societies rely on virtual world platforms that can be targeted by potential attackers. Since global networks defy borders and limit state jurisdiction, they are harder to defend and allow potential attackers to act below the threshold of detection and attribution. Hybrid threats also benefit from the unprecedent speed and scope of information. This is not new in principle, but it has reached game- changing levels. On the one hand, managing this massive flow of information is just prohibitive for NATO and its member states; on the other hand, high speed of circulation translates into increased operational tempo.¶ Hybrid threats may take aim at a variety of targets, yet particularly concerning are offensive actions that might lead to societal polarization, elite disagreement and biased perceptions of foreign actors. These actions have the potential to affect decision-making at different levels, even undermining democratic states’ institutions. Accordingly, these hybrid threats could undermine decision-making process of Allies – and by reflex, NATO’s too. Decision makers face in particular three main set of problems when crafting a response to hybrid threats.¶ 1) How to respond in non-escalatory ways? Since hybrid attacks exploit the grey zone to create ambiguity, including by manipulating the threshold of detection and granting plausible deniability, decision makers are faced with the risk of overreaction.¶ 2) How to respond in democratic ways? Potential attackers may severely impair the decision-making process of democratic systems, putting under stress, for example, the constraint to abide by domestic and international law.¶ 3) How to get public support? Since hybrid threats are usually covered or difficult to attribute, policy makers also have to persuade the public opinion of the very same existence of the threat.