Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is key – it provides a framework for understanding and integrating AI

Lucarelli et al 2021 - Professor at the University of Bologna, member of the Board of Directors of the Forum on the Problems of Peace and War and of the Institute of International Affairs

Sonia Lucarelli Alessandro Marrone Francesco N. Moro “Executive Summary” Nato Decision-Making In The Age Of Big Data And Artificial Intelligence, Nato Allied Command Transformation Università Di Bologna Istituto Affari Internazionali

The AI Adoption in the Defense Domain and NATO’s Role. In discussing what AI will mean for allied militaries and the Alliance as such, a basic question should be addressed: is AI a technological revolution or is it an instance of technological evolution? Different pieces of evidence can support both interpretations. It would probably be hard for Allies, from a political perspective, to adapt swiftly to a rapid technological revolution. NATO approach, because of the consensus characterising its procedures, will have to be more evolutionary, granular and nuanced. In any case, it is unlikely to see in the next future AI making decisions for the North Atlantic Council (NAC) or the Nuclear Planning Group (NPG). There are psychological, cultural, organizational, political as well as technical reasons for this. The journey to AI is likely to be rather troublesome. Agile software development, for instance, enables the development of superior software but, at the same time, also calls for different procedures, organizational structures and processes, touching upon organizations’ identities, missions and culture.

Another topical issue is the private-public partnership on AI. This is key in the AI race between the US and China – possibly leading to disadvantages for Allies vis-à-vis China – and in the relations between NATO and major civilian companies working on AI and Big Data. There is also the fundamental need to ensure interoperability in a fragmented scenario in terms of the Allies’ adoption of AI technologies. NATO has historically been an important player in the processes of standardization and could be such also in this case. In this context, some creativity may be needed: for instance, should NATO provide cloud computing services, namely enablers, the same way it provides air-space management or ground surveillance? Could the Alliance envision an integration of nationally-owned AI assets as it does for the integrated air and missile defense? These are important questions which, however, highlight the fact that defense is a sovereign issue and most decisions are taken by national governments, not by NATO as such.

The Alliance could play a prominent role in the AI domain. For instance, NATO could establish an AI champion to help Allies understand, adopt and integrate AI. Such champion could start with small projects aiming at validating the effectiveness of the solution, and then it could help Allies in training. A key, related issue in this regard is education and training. Similarly, the importance of wargames, simulations and experimentations is going to grow, and NATO has a role to play here, as the unique avenue to convene allied military and political bodies.

Lucarelli et al 2021 - Professor at the University of Bologna, member of the Board of Directors of the Forum on the Problems of Peace and War and of the Institute of International Affairs

Sonia Lucarelli Alessandro Marrone Francesco N. Moro “Technological Changes And A Transformed International Security Environment” Nato Decision-Making In The Age Of Big Data And Artificial Intelligence, Nato Allied Command Transformation Università Di Bologna Istituto Affari Internazional

Digital revolution has substantially transformed the world we live in, providing great opportunities but also making societies more vulnerable and transforming the meaning of state borders. Technology makes external interferences cheaper, faster and all-encompassing: citizens can potentially become direct targets of information warfare, all members of a society can be part of conflicts one way or another. From advanced weaponry to command and control, most security-related domains are undergoing deep transformations as data availability and transmission increase exponentially. This is especially true as the emergence of so-called hybrid tactics contributes to universalize the battlefield. Also, attackers may lose control of their offensive cyber weapons, and ‘collateral damages’ across the private sector and the public worldwide might be more and more difficult to contain. Less visible, yet important challenges connected with Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) also exist. For instance, data overload can create problems for decision- makers that are unable to detect important signals. Losing sight of how machines make their calculations – a somewhat inherent feature of Artificial Intelligence (AI) – can hinder deeper understanding of phenomena as well as learning, besides having dense ethical implications.

A crucial question for Western societies and governments is how to deal with technological changes by exploiting their many benefits while managing to limit their risks. Broadly speaking, observers have long noticed the potentialities of technologies in the security domain: better situational awareness, early warning against threats and risks, the ability to prevent and/or stop attacks to happen, the use of technology against the adversaries’ own technologies, and eventually deterrence of high-end hybrid warfare or, at least, the increase of resilience against it. In particular, in order to harness the potential of new technologies, higher levels of security are needed. While internet is unfortunately not secure by design, it has to be somehow retrofit to guarantee a certain level of protection – for instance by avoiding a single point of failure, developing better firewalls, etc. Ultimately, the digital revolution poses challenges to decision makers both as potential users of new technologies and as leaders of targeted societies. Learning to achieve political aims through the support of technological innovations and at the same time acquiring the ability to prevent and manage interferences, if not attacks, have become paramount.

However, achieving such results is not only about engineering. Technologies need ad hoc governance, organizations and skilled users to properly function. Actually, history is full of examples of good technologies that were improperly used and/or unable to provide the expected gains. Therefore, a joint, multi-disciplinary efforts is needed to think and manage technologies in a more comprehensive and secure way across various domains. For instance, the very same design of AI needs exchanges with social scientists in order to limit

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.