Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1AC’s threat perceptions of China’s AI advantage are informed by vague intelligence and exaggerated threat assessments – that produces a US-China security spiral, turning case by making conflict more likely

Arif 16 (Muhamad Arif, researcher at The Habibie Center’s ASEAN Studies Program. He currently is a lecturer at the University of Indonesia and teaches several topics, including International Security Institutions, “How Threat Assessment Could Become Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: Case of U.S.-China Relations,” Global: Jurnal Politik Internasional. https://scholarhub.ui.ac.id/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1029&context=global) //AA

China’s expansion of national interests which followed by its military modernization alarms the other side of the Pacific. An observation on U.S. official documents reveals how U.S. is alarmed with rapid military modernization of China. 10 As early as 2006, U.S. has been aware that China, among other countries, has the greatest potential to compete militarily with the U.S. In terms of military technology, U.S. is also aware that the gap with China is closing and unless U.S. could formulate counter strategies, its military advantages would soon be offset (U.S. Department of Defense, 2006, p. 29). The tone of anxiety about China’s military modernization has not much changed years afterwards. In latest edition of Quadrennial Defense Review Report (2014, p. 6), it is stated that “In the coming years, countries such as China will continue seeking to counter U.S. strengths using anti-access and area-denial (A2/AD) approaches and by employing other new cyber and space control technologies. Similar notion is found in 2012 Department of Defense’s document of strategic guidance in which stated that “States such as China and Iran will continue to pursue asymmetric means to counter our power projection capabilities” (Panneta & Obama, 2012). From these publications we can also get a sense on how it is very difficult, if not entirely impossible, for states to acquire complete information regarding their adversaries’ current and future intentions. This problem is worse in the case of China whose authoritarian government is not really familiar with the idea of transparency. Thus, U.S. seems to have no other choice than just equate China’s increasing military capabilities with unfriendly intentions. In Quadrennial Defense Review Report 2006, it is stated that “… the United States, its allies and partners must also hedge against the possibility that a major or emerging power could choose a hostile path in the future (U.S. Department of Defense, 2006, p. 28).” It does not require a rocket science to identify the region where there is an emerging power as well as a number of U.S. allies. In Quadrennial Defense Review 2014, it is stated that “… the rapid pace and comprehensive scope of China’s military modernization continues, combined with a relative lack of transparency and openness from China’s leaders regarding both military capabilities and intentions (U.S. Department of Defense, 2014).” The general observations on some publications of U.S. government reveals how U.S. feels, at the very least, alarmed by the rapid military modernization of China. Once this hostile image attached, China’s further military modernization is regarded as a proof to that hostile image. This can be shown, for example, on how U.S. dubs China as developing what it calls as Anti-Access/Area Denial capabilities which can be used, and believed is going to be used, to deter and counter U.S. involvement in the events of conflict in China’s Global Jurnal Politik Internasional 18(2) 125 periphery. Applying our theoretical framework of “spiral model,” this stage can be regarded as one when U.S. applying the first logic of overestimating the hostility of its rival, in this case, China. Feeling threatened by the perceived-as-hostile strategic behaviour of China, U.S. starts to respond. In the midst of economic struggle and defence budget cut, U.S. tries to check the rise of China mainly through what it calls as “rebalancing” strategy which involves an intensification of alliances and basing strategies. The strategy covers U.S. basing in Darwin and Guam, the provision of advanced naval weapon systems such Patriot missiles and Aegis system to its alliances, and also diplomatic and economic initiatives such as Trans-Pacific Partnership which exclude China. Hillary Clinton’s “America’s Pacific Century,” (2011) one of the earliest record that lie down U.S. strategic pivot to Asia-Pacific, provides the stated rationale behind the strategy which is to uphold U.S. leadership commitment in the key driver area of current global politics. Interesting to note here how Clinton frames that U.S. rebalancing is not desired by U.S. only, but also by the region itself, hence justifying U.S. continuing presence. Another important note is how U.S. seems to truly believe that it has been a Pacific state. This statement can be regarded as a way U.S. tries to frame that its presence expansion in Asia-Pacific is for benign purposes. U.S. “rebalancing” strategy, which was initially intended to preserve stability in the region, turns out generate the very opposite outcome. China considers U.S., with its “rebalancing” strategy as a revisionist power that seeks to curtail China’s political influence and harms China’s interests; as China rises, the U.S. will resist (Nathan & Scobell, 2012). This view appears to be much influenced by China’s understanding of U.S., as well as China’s view of the international system and how to behave in such system.11 The sense of China being threatened by U.S. strategic behaviour can also be found in China’s official documents. In 2008 edition of China’s National Defense (2009), U.S. military deployment realignment and its strengthened military alliances with countries like Japan are regarded as influencing the complexity of the regional security environment. That U.S. continues to sell advanced weapons systems to Taiwan is also regarded as an infringement to the “one China” policy and U.S.-China joint communiqes. These two issues have been persistently raised afterwards (China's National Defense in 2010, 2011). 2014 Shangri-La Dialogue perhaps is the perfect evidence that shows how China is feeling threatened by U.S. strategic behaviour in Asia-Pacific, and vice versa. Muhamad Arif 126 Responding to U.S. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel that criticized China for its “destabilizing, unilateral actions” particularly in the South China Sea, Lieutenant General Wang Guanzhong, the Chinese military’s deputy chief of general staff said that Hagel’s speech was designed to “create trouble and make provocations” (Han, Barnes, & Page, 2014). Lt. Gen. Wang continued by saying that Hagel’s speech was “full of hegemony, full of words of threat and intimidation,” and part of “a provocative challenge against China.” This speech was then backed by another Chinese official, Major General Zhu Chenghu, who said in an interview, “If you take China as an enemy, China will absolutely become the enemy of the U.S. (Han, Barnes, & Page, 2014).” From this exchanges of strong words by high ranking officials from both China and U.S, we can get a sense of antagonistic, even hostility, in the relations between the two. The sense of being threatened by U.S.’ “rebalancing” strategy leads China to intensify its military modernization. China continues to increase its defence expenditures, until today. Moreover, China intensifies the development of advanced weapons systems that provide it with capability to neutralize U.S. force in the Pacific. These capabilities, which U.S. calls as A2/AD capabilities –which in itself is U.S.’ overestimation of China’s hostility- ranges from fifth-generation fighter aircrafts, advanced intermediate and medium-range conventional ballistic missiles, long-range land-attack and anti-ship cruise missiles, counter-space weapons to offensive cyber capabilities. And as the “spiral model” postulates, U.S. has been investing considerable amount of resources to develop strategy to counter China’s counter-strategy against U.S. presence in Asia-Pacific. In other words, the conflict between U.S. and China is spiralling.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.