Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Threat construction unfairly justifies a victim story that US policymakers use to justify radical and extreme policy action

Yuan and Fu, 20 (Zhengqing Yuan, Senior Fellow at the Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences; Qiang Fu, Associate Professor at the School of Foreign Studies of Central University of Finance and Economics, 10 July, 2020, Chinese Journal of International Politics, https://academic.oup.com/cjip/article-abstract/13/3/419/5869540?redirectedFrom=fulltext)

However, it should be noted that, in the original Greek text, Thucydides himself does not explain the war as a structural mindset. It is Allison who inserts a structural frame when emplotting the war, one that perfectly captures in people’s minds the schema of a rising power and the ruling power, thus contributing to its popularity.108 This structural interpretation of Sino–US relations and the world arena is, at best, just one of the possible ways of narrating the reality. Other alternatives, like ‘a new model of major-power relationship’ or ‘a community of shared future for mankind’, can also tell a coherent story with the same facts. For example, through the lens of ‘a community of shared future for mankind’, the AIIB and the Belt and Road Initiative can be seen as evidence of the public goods China offers towards achieving with the world common prosperity, whereas through the lens of the Thucydides Trap, they would be rendered as evidence of China’s move to replace American hegemony. As is explained in the theoretical section, threat stories can be self-fulfilling. Once the story of power competition between a rising power and a ruling power is accepted, people will depend on it to make sense of the world and take actions. In other words, the focus of US policy towards China turns from engaging with China to preparing for the worst. China is first and foremost perceived as an economic threat that presents a global challenge. Most of this discourse falls under two kinds of narrative template: one where China challenges US economic hegemony; the other story of victimhood in which the United States has suffered huge job losses, a serious decline in its manufacturing industries, and an enormous trade deficit due to China’s unfair trade practices and competition. These two modes of narration are two sides of the same coin which differ only in their emphases. One the one hand, China is an economic challenger. China’s challenge in hightech sectors is a salient node of the threat discourse network. Traditionally, the United States has taken technological leadership to be an indispensable feature of its hegemonic identity, as it signifies both cultural superiority and a guarantee of US economic prosperity and military superiority.109 But now the United States increasingly believes that its economic competitiveness is under serious threat from China’s advance in high-tech industries. What most alarms Americans is China’s high-tech initiatives, especially the ‘Made in China 2025’. A 2019 senate committee report chaired by Senator Marco Rubio articulates that China’s ‘Made in China 2025’ seeks to be ‘the global leader in innovation and manufacturing’, and that such a goal ‘would be an unacceptable outcome for American workers’.110 Another significant node of China’s economic challenge discourse network is that of China’s challenge to the world economic order dominated by the United States. According to these stories, as China’s economy continues to grow, China will rewrite the existing rules of the world economy and reshape the international political economy in a way that favours its interests. For example, China’s proposal to reform the current international monetary system is perceived as challenging dollar hegemony, and the newly established Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank is interpreted as a move to replace the US-led World Bank and International Monetary Fund. On the other hand, the discourse tells the story of US victimhood. Similar to what the revisionists did in 1980s, proponents of China threats also invoke a victim story to make sense of China’s economic rise and the United States’ underperformance in competition with China. President Trump is a major advocate of this story. In his State of the Union address in 2019, he said: ‘We are now making it clear to China that, after years of targeting our industries and stealing our intellectual property, the theft of American jobs and wealth has come to an end’.111 In crafting this story, many negative images and memories of China, in American novels and movies, have been cashed in on, and ‘China the thief’ and ‘China the manipulator’ are now two widely used narrative templates. Within the metaphorical frame of ‘thief’, Chinese government agencies and companies have proactively engaged in economic and industrial espionage that has caused huge economic losses for American corporations and great harm to their economic competitiveness. For example, an investigation report by the Office of the United States Trade Representative in 2018 states that China is the most active actor in economic espionage, having gained ‘unauthorised access to a wide range of commercially-valuable business information’.112 Notably, cyber theft and intellectual property theft are the most common memes in the discourse. In the manipulator narrative, meanwhile, China exercises unfair trade practices through manipulating exchange rates, monetary policy, subsidies, etc. to promote exports and restrict imports, resulting in the failure of American companies, an enormous trade deficit, and immense job losses; and at the same time, China manipulates its economy through such measures as industry policy, market access restriction, forced technology transfers, and government procurement, among others. A 2018 White House report states that, in order to dominate high-tech industries, the Chinese government has carried out industrial policy though state-sponsored theft, forced technology transfers, economic coercion, information harvesting, and statebacked investment in high technologies.113 As to the ‘thief’ and ‘manipulator’ tales about China, such stories can also blind people. For example, the allegations of China’s currency manipulation and forced technology transfers may to a large extent be apocryphal or at least exaggerated, and rather than being made victims, US companies benefit from China, as even certain hawks have noticed that ‘Americans are investing more in China’ amid the trade war.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.