Speech acts against China such as the debt-trap narrative legitimize securitization
Lupovici 21 Lupovici, Amir. “The Dual-Use Security Dilemma and the Social Construction of Insecurity.” Contemporary Security Policy, vol. 42, no. 3, 2021, pp. 257–285., Amir Lupovici is a senior lecturer in the School of Political Science, Government and International Affairs at Tel Aviv University and a research fellow in the Interdisciplinary Cyber Research Center at Tel Aviv University. He was a faculty fellow in the School of International Service at American University (2017-2018) and a visiting scholar in the Centre for Conflict Resolution of International Conflicts at the University of Copenhagen (2014) https://doi.org/10.1080/13523260.2020.1866845. //parip
This literature review illustrates how China has been securitized because of ideological and perceptional differences. The literature demonstrates how the BRI has been securitized but not explicitly because of ideological and perceptional differences, rather there is more of a focus on the economic impact of China’s policy. While Singh (2020) and Almén et al’s (2021) highlight the BRI’s debt-trap issue, there is substantial controversy concerning the legitimacy of the debt-trap threat. However, by using securitization theory focused on post structural aspects as Song (2015) demonstrates, we can gain a deeper recognition of the performative aspect of speech acts and if securitizing actors legitimize the debt trap narrative. Post structural 10 securitization theory, as noted by Hansen (2011: 358), ‘may enable a more critical engagement with the politics of security’, for example, the power-knowledge nexus and the ways in which discourses on security construct the objects of which they speak. This thesis contends with the reviewed literature that China has been securitized. However, the aim of this thesis is to demonstrate the distinctiveness of poststructural securitization theory in analyzing the perceptions and ideological differences concerning the BRI. Scholarly analyses have mainly focused on the economic and military sectors of security in relation to the threat China presents, therefore examining the differences in ideology and perceptions in relation to the BRI and American strategy aspects outlined by Chengqiu (2020) will aid in determining what other security sectors are affected. 3. Theoretical Framework In order to answer the research question “How do speech acts contribute to the securitization of China?”, it is necessary to discuss securitization theory developed by the Copenhagen School. This theory has been widely used in previous research concerning China, and therefore it is advantageous for this thesis to widen the understanding of how discourse concerning the BRI has been connected to security through the process of securitization. Additionally, Hansen expands securitization theory by (re)adding elements of poststructuralism. This part of the thesis has two purposes: first, laying the foundation for this thesis’ operational framework of poststructural securitization, and secondly for the utilization of it in the analysis chapter. 3.1 Securitization Theory In Buzan, Wæver, and Jaap’s (1998) revolutionary book Security: A New Framework for Analysis, they address two conceptual developments: sectoral analysis and Wæver’s concept of securitization. Securitization involves framing an issue as ‘a special kind of politics or as above politics’ (Buzan et al, 1998: 23), therefore can be viewed as a ‘more extreme form of politicization’ (ibid). One of the distinguishing features of this theory is the framing of a subject as an existential threat and a ‘specific rhetorical structure’ (ibid), as in if the problem is not addressed quickly, it will be too late and we will not be able to rectify it. Securitization places emphasis on speech acts which assume that speeches are not only to express an idea or present information but also to perform an action. Speech acts also illustrate the power knowledge nexus. ‘We are subject to the production of truth through power and we cannot 11 exercise power except through the production of truth. Thus the production of a truth, or the creation of knowledge through a discourse, is an exercise of power.’ (Ibrahim, 2005: 164). Therefore, the securitizing actor performing a speech act is exercising power over the intended audience. However, securitization theory has been subject to many criticisms. It has been critiqued for being too static and not being able to take on the developments in the security field, Derrida criticized securitization for being too strict in evaluating the success of the speech act, and Howell and Richter-Montpetit (2019) have even criticized it for being Eurocentric and racist. Hansen (2011) recognized the shortcomings of Buzan et al’s (1998) work and expanded on it by (re)adding elements of poststructuralism. In a sense, it is re-adding poststructural elements because securitization and speech act are rooted in poststructuralism.