The hegemonic position of the US in the squo and expansion of Chinese ideology has lead to securitization of the “Chinese Threat”
Gilkey, Qiana, 2022, (Malmö University, Faculty of Culture and Society (KS), Department of Global Political Studies (GPS).) "How do speech acts contribute to the securitization of China?: A critical discourse analysis of perceptional and ideological differences in American discourse vis-à-vis the Belt and Road Initiative.," DIVA, https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?dswid=-6447&pid=diva2%3A1667683
The hegemonic position held by America and its position in the international system as a dominant state is central to its identity. As Fukuyama’s (1989) article noted, the collapse of the Soviet Union shaped American identity as a global hegemon, an example of them as a leading Western liberal and democratic state, and a state which aims to spread liberal and democratic values. The US perceives its hegemonic position, therefore its core identity, as being threatened by China. The previous subsections have demonstrated how there has been a rise in securitizing discourse regarding the BRI which affects multiple sectors, not solely the economic and military sectors. The analysis also demonstrates the role that conflicting ideologies play in securitizing speech acts. While explicitly stating that China is using the BRI to actively spread its authoritarian and communist values in the economic sector, the analysis shows how the perceived ideological expansion and perceived threats further contribute to the securitization of China and the construction of the ‘China threat’. The securitization of China is in no way a new and untouched subject of study, however, the use of poststructuralism has been underutilized. The aim of this thesis was to explore how securitization regarding the BRI also includes differences in ideologies and perceptions, as ample research has mainly focused on the economic, military, and strategic elements. The use of Fairclough’s three-dimensional model along with the theoretical framework developed by Hansen has been used to highlight the perceptional and ideological differences which play key roles in the securitization of China. It also reveals the latent power relations and how the discourse by US elites reproduces these unequal power relationships. The method and theoretical framework were chosen to explore how historical context and social contexts at a specific period in time affect speech acts. The articles reviewed mainly focus on the economic and military sectors, and while this is acknowledged to play a substantial role, the ideological differences have shown to also securitize the political and societal sectors as well. The inclusion of more sectors provides a more robust and deeper understanding of the securitization process and how it contributes to the further securitization of China. The addition of poststructuralism contributes to the security field by emphasizing different ontologies and epistemologies, which only serves to deepen the understanding of the securitization process and if it will be successful or not. It also allows us to understand why US-Sino relations have been strained and how this can affect the current international system dominated by Western liberal and democratic concepts. The guiding argument was that differences in ideologies and perceptions contribute to the securitization of China. In the analysis, we can clearly note the increase in securitizing language being utilized by political elites over the years. This may be due to the change in the presidency or the fact that the BRI was implemented over a longer period, nonetheless, there is a clear correlation in how the discourse has framed China as a threat in a more obvious way. The language has also reflected the rising inclusion of the general public. The historical construction of the American identity in the international system has been shown to contextualize how their identity being threatened plays a more considerable role in why there is an escalation of securitizing discourse. Securitizing the BRI, therefore further securitizing China as a whole, is advantageous to the US as these efforts will assist in preserving the current status quo, therefore retaining their unipolar and hegemonic identity.