The 1AC’s humanitarian appeal to climate change is not neutral, but permeated by a ‘bunkerization’ of the aid industry wherein humanitarianism is tied to security actors thus rendering the space of aid intervention a space of security. Their scholarship equivocates disaster with conflict – the first step in the naturalization and depoliticization of warfare characterized by militarized humanitarianism.
McCormack and Gilbert 22 - Killian McCormack is a Research Associate in the Department of Geography and Planning at the University of Toronto, where he completed his PhD in 2020. His research examines the intersections of militarization, global health, and geopolitics, with a specific focus on the US military’s global health engagement practices. Emily Gilbert is Professor of Canadian Studies and Geography at the University of Toronto, where she is also Vice-Principal of University College. Her research examines contemporary forms of securitization and militarization, across multiple domains (eg borders, war, climate change), with a particular focus on north America. She is an Editor at the journal Security Dialogue, [“The Geopolitics of Militarism and Humanitarianism”, University of Toronto, Progress in Human Geography, 2022, Vol. 46(1) 179–197, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/03091325211032267]RA
Military response is also mobilized domestically in response to crises, often with respect to marginalized and alienated populations as with Hurricane Katrina in 2005 where the predominantly black population was targeted by state violence (Smith, 2006), or with Indigenous activism, whether the 1991 Oka crisis in Canada or the ongoing Dakota pipeline protests in the US (Estes, 2019). Yet militaries are also undertaking pre-emptive action. For example, this is evident in Operation Continuing Promise, launched in 2008 by US Southern Command, to provide basic medical care to vulnerable communities in Latin America and the Caribbean in anticipation of potential future crisis, which Joe Bryan (2015) has shown renders humanitarianism as a means of waging war without end. In this way, humanitarian practices and spaces form a part of a larger geography of war, anticipating and pre-empting future conflict by deploying militaries in the present. Militaries are also involved in the securitization of channels of global migration. Geographers have underlined the ways that borders, and the work they do, are extended internally and externally through appeals to humanitarian care and control, which paradoxically serves to reinforce and securitize the very national and regional borders that asylum seekers are trying to cross (Islemen, 2018; Jones, 2016; Pallister-Wilkins, 2018). Of course, the securitization and militarization of migration is not new. But the technologies of migration management – and the forms of circumvention or resistance that are mobilized – are taking new shape and form. What begins as a ‘humanitarian’ operation can quickly devolve into a more interventionist and militarized operation of capture, containment and control. For example, both NATO and the EU have launched military operations in response to the ongoing refugee crisis in the Mediterranean. Glenda Garelli and Martina Tazzioli (2018) have argued that although their stated aim is to protect migrants and disrupt smuggler’s networks, these missions act to dissuade migration flows through the central and eastern Mediterranean and disrupt the potential of certain populations to move through space. Migrants are both the subjects to be saved, and those who are prevented from travelling – a phenomenon that is not limited to Europe (Loyd et al., 2016; Mountz, 2020). Recent moves to militarize the response to refugees have been fuelled by the conflicts and war in Middle East and Africa – paradoxically, the means of war are increasingly being used to regulate the consequences of war – but discourses around militarization have also proliferated with the anticipated rise of ‘climate refugees’ in response to climate change (Gilbert, 2012; Hartmann, 2010). In all these examples, the nexus of militarized-humanitarianism is leading to more violence, rather than its mitigation. As Fassin and Pandolfi (2010: 12) have argued, disasters and conflict are rendered equivalent behind the moral discourse of humanitarianism, prompting military intervention or militarized responses, and leading to the ‘naturalization – or depoliticization – of war’. Citizens are turned into ‘passive beneficiaries’ of the responsibility to protect, transformed from rights-bearing agents to ‘recipients of charity’ (Mamdani, 2009: 264). Weizman (2011: 52) has noted that the blurring of roles of militaries and humanitarians has led belligerents ‘to construe aid workers as enemies, an integral part of the occupying force’, rendering them more vulnerable to attack and violence (see also Foley, 2008). In turn, this has resulted in what Mark Duffield (2012) has termed a bunkerization of the aid industry, with the presence of humanitarian organizations becoming increasingly fortified in conflict zones, further tying them to security actors and rendering the space of aid intervention also a space of security. This reflects a hardening of boundaries that characterizes militarized humanitarianism, with specific spaces of security produced that reinforce divides between those who save and those who will be saved. However, as Jennifer Fluri has shown, attempts to secure the lives of international aid workers in conflict zones can also render civilian bodies more vulnerable, for example, through the disruptions arising from highly securitized compounds, to the violations of private spaces (Fluri, 2011). Despite these vulnerabilities, military engagement in humanitarian response is used to legitimate it as a force of good, which obfuscates its lethal force. As new crises unfold, from disasters caused by climate change to health emergencies such as the COVID-19 pandemic, geographers will need to continue to interrogate the militarized responses that are marshalled in the name of humanitarianism, as they take new shape and form.