Securitizing rhetoric about climate migrants results in violence against minority group because of the increase in risky border crossing into the EU.
Wojciech et al 22 - Deputy director of the Institute of Political Sciences and Administration of the UO, Assistant professor - Department of Regional Studies Wojciech Opioła1a, Bartosz Czepila , Marcin Dębickib , Ewa Ganowicza , Justyna Kajtac , Katalin Kovályd , Łukasz Mollb , Natalia Niedźwiecka-Iwańczakb , Elżbieta Opiłowskab , Grigorii Pidgrushniy April 25, 2022 “Editorial: War and politics. The 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine and refugee crisis on the eastern EU border from the perspective of border studies” https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Wojciech-Opiola/publication/360557978_War_and_politics_The_2022_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine_and_refugee_crisis_on_the_eastern_EU_border_from_the_perspective_of_border_studies/links/6284ffaa14a92616f0426adc/War-and-politics-The-2022-Russian-invasion-of-Ukraine-and-refugee-crisis-on-the-eastern-EU-border-from-the-perspective-of-border-studies.pdf
For decades, we could observe two parallel but contrary processes – debordering and rebordering – a decreasing and at the same time increasing impact of borders. Whereas the former was linked to the process of political and economic European integration and globalization, the latter was justified by security measures. Borderlands studies have followed these developments and analyzed the changes generated by Europeanization, globalization and the recent revival of nationalism. Increasingly, the migration crises brought to the fore the question of the ethical dimension of the bordering process. By taking into consideration that borders do not only divide physical space but are also used to sort people according to the degree of their belonging, Laine (2021, p. 747) questions the state-centric thinking and emphasizes that “borders carry considerable moral weight in determining ethical responsibilities towards those who are not considered to belong”. However, since people live in networked societies today, and not in isolated national communities, the humanitarian principle is not the sole argument that borders should be made more permeable. Hence, Laine proposes the ethics of unbounded inclusiveness to move away from the nation state-centric form of organization and the rigid borders and to consider alternative forms of belongingness towards more inclusive societies.
Nevertheless, as the optimistic vision of a borderless world has already vanished, and the idea of cosmopolitical citizenship (Balibar, 2010) has not been implemented by nation states yet, we can rather observe border securitization in Europe than debordering policies (cf. Prokkola, 2021; Léonard & Kaunert, 2020). The tightening of borders and the adoption of more restrictive migration policies results in the increase of clandestine journeys and more desperate and risky attempts to enter EU member states. Thus, securitization which leads to violence, injustice and bad treatment of migrants, also provokes humanitarian impulses on the side of public opinion, NGOs, and migrant activists’ groups. In effect, securitization and humanitarianism at the border are two sides of the same coin: the former is supplemented by the latter, and the latter is determined by the former. This double-bind can be described as ‘hostipitable’ (both hostile and hospitable) condition of EU border regimes (Vaughan-Williams, 2015). What migrants face when they approach Europe is the state of indifference between security measures and human rights. The policies which should help to differentiate between unwelcomed invaders and deserving refugees only contribute to arbitrary treatment of people on the move. The role of states in having control over national borders (and their permeability to different categories of people), but also over boundaries, which relate to social exclusion and inclusion (Donnan & Wilson, 2007) – is strongly evident in current events.