Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Western security thinking premised on the promotion of liberal international norms is predicated on securitizing and imagined self-image against a racialized, illiberal, and irrational Other

Pan, 2021

(Chengxin, Associate Professor of International Relations at the School of Humanities and Social Sciences at Deakin University, “Racialised politics of (in)security and the COVID-19 Westfailure,” Critical Studies on Security, Vol. 9, Iss. 1, 2021, pp. 40-45, https://doi.org/10.1080/21624887.2021.1904195, accessed 7/2/2022, ZW)

Mainstream Western security thinking is predicated on a self-gratifying imaginative geography: the world is divided roughly into two contrasting zones, one marked by community, order, and security and the other by disorder, insecurity, and threat. These imagined binaries are both underpinned by and emblematic of a thinly disguised Orientalist, Eurocentric, and ultimately racist idea, which equates the former zone more or less with whites and the West, and the latter with non-whites (Barkawi and Laffey 2006; Howell and Richter-Montpetit 2019). The idea, often passed off as fact (through the Western-dominated subfield of security studies), has been constitutive of the highly racialised realities in international relations (Bell 2013; Carrozza, Danewid, and Pauls 2017; Ling 2017; Howell and Richter-Montpetit 2020).

Although by no means unique to the West, racism is a key source code of mainstream Western theory and practice of security. Security presupposes a subject, namely, what or who needs security or should feel secure, which, in turn, implies what or whom is to be secured from or against. Central to security studies, therefore, is an implicit ontological bifurcation between the subject of security and its threat. And the security/threat boundaries are often drawn along a ‘colour line’ (Anievas, Manchanda, and Shilliam 2015).

The racially-mediated binaries in security thinking and practice are enabled above all by an epistemic hierarchy, which insists on ‘the inherent superiority of one’s culture over all others’ (Le Melle 2009, 77). Indeed, racism is first and foremost epistemic racism, which is ‘the foundational form … of racism’ (Grosfoguel 2010, 29). The West’s self-representation as the quintessential modern knowing subject, who has the rational capacity to know the objective world (Pan 2012), is epistemic racism par excellence. Since ‘[k]nowing is then linked to the possibility of control of the known’ (Walker 1988, 51), the knowing Western subject can enjoy certainty, dominance, and security, hence the self-image as a zone of security. The West’s epistemic certainty thus helps lay the groundwork for its sense of moral, political, economic, civilisational, and geostrategic superiority vis-à-vis other races and peoples, whose ‘epistemic inadequacy’ makes them irrational, ignorant, uncivilised, and ontologically threatening (even if occasionally blissfully innocent and/or exotically attractive).

Threats from ‘zones of insecurity’ have taken many forms: tribalism, terrorism, crime, disease, overpopulation, unregulated migration, espionage, unfair trade practice, anarchical, illiberal power politics, or some combinations of the above (Kaplan 1994; Huntington 1996). Intellectually sophisticated and racially agnostic as they are, many (Western) security concepts and approaches are in effect about methodologies of eliminating, minimising, or containing the (largely non-Western) ‘zone of insecurity’, whether through democracy promotion, norm diffusion, free trade, transnational activism, emancipatory intervention and developmental assistance, or by ways of alliance building and expansion, forward defence, military deterrence, containment, power balancing, and border control.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.