NATO’s addiction to security is increasing threats and insecurity, and perpetuating their and others addiction.
Porter 10 (Patrick Porter, Patrick Porter is Chair in International Security and Strategy at the University of Birmingham. He is a Fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, NATO'S FUTURE: Hooked On Security, TheWorldToday.org, November 2010)//KS
Currently, pressing menaces to our way of life are played out through banks not tanks. Yet NATO is not content with this staggering historical success, it cannot get enough security. Hungry to justify its existence and fascinated with itself, it ! scans the horizon for threats and the shadows of threats. NATO's role and limits have not been finally settled. Neither operations in the Sudan, Bosnia, Kosovo and I Afghanistan, nor new missions, nor new members, resolve the issue. There are endless arguments for growing it, redefining it, abandoning it, even for an Atlantic-Russian super-alliance. This identity question is not abstract. The issue of NATO's domain was bloodily raised in Russia's 2008 war over South Ossetia and Abkhazia, it divides the Ukrainian people, and in Afghanistan soldiers are dying and losing limbs to keep the alliance afloat. Its visionaries point to an unstable, complex world, a turbulent frontier on the periphery forever threatening our core. They warn of terrorists armed with apocalyptic weapons, of failing states and stealthy cyber attacks, a web of chain reactions and chaos. Their remedy is expanding membership and forward leaning offensives into failed states, or new game-changing defenses such as a missile shield system. And in the age of human security, defense means the export of Atlantic market democracy to stabilize the dark places of the earth and widen our defensive perimeter. Addiction increases in intensity even while the addict loses sight of the side effects. With peace and stability our forbears could not have dreamt of, NATO's addiction and identity crisis has become dangerous in itself. If there is a threat, it lies partly in NATO's messianic restlessness; its innocent vision of threats not flowing partly from its own behavior, but being simply ťout there'; its ideological fundamentalism; its own self-perception as the natural guardian of world order with obviously pure intentions ; and its exhausting, self-defeating pursuit of relevance.