Mutual securitization between Russia and the United States creates a “zero sum game” and validates extreme measures in the name of “security.”
Simanov 21 - Samara University
Егор Simanov “HOW COULD NATO AND RUSSIA CO-EXIST IN THE TIME OF THE INFORMATION AND "HYBRID" WARS? “No 1 (18) (2021) Pages: 100-105 https://journals.ssau.ru/smus/article/view/8782/en_US
The current condition of relations between Russia and the West, which consists of the NATO member-states, tends to chaotization and elimination of the institutions providing the architecture of regional and global security.
Both Russia and NATO are concerned about ensuring their security. Russian actions to strengthen their defenses (modernization of the army, military exercises) are viewed by NATO as a threat to the security of its member countries. At the same time, the expansion of NATO to the east (the admission of Eastern European countries into the ranks of the Alliance, with the ensuing conduct of military exercises, the introduction of Western standards, and the creation of new military infrastructure) is viewed by Russia as bringing the Alliance closer to the Russian borders. Here we see a classic manifestation of the "zero-sum game" when the success of one side in defending its security is perceived by the other side as a threat to its security and leads to countermeasures.
Moreover, it’s possible to use the concept of securitization proposed by the Copenhagen school of security studies to describe actors’ moves [1]. Official documents in the field of security, such as the National Security Strategy of the Russian Federation and the Concept of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation, NATO 2030 Report, especially the concepts and strategies of national security of the Alliance member-states, define each other in the categories of “military threats” (in case of Russia) and immediate existential threats (in case of NATO and member countries). The parties concerned or "securitized" certain aspects of international interaction: they translate them into the category of threats to the existence or integrity of the state or security in the region, which makes it possible to use or "legitimize" extraordinary means to counter this threat.
The situation is complicated by the use of images of "friend or foe" associated with the rhetoric of securitization in order to resolve the domestic issues rather than those of foreign policy. Such attitude is typical, for Russia to a lesser degree than for the "West" due to the more heterogeneous nature of the "West" itself.