The aff’s threat construction of dual-use technology causes security dilemmas
Lupovici 21 Lupovici, Amir. “The Dual-Use Security Dilemma and the Social Construction of Insecurity.” Taylor & Francis, 6 Jan. 2021, Amir Lupovici is a senior lecturer in the School of Political Science, Government and International Affairs at Tel Aviv University and a research fellow in the Interdisciplinary Cyber Research Center at Tel Aviv University. He was a faculty fellow in the School of International Service at American University (2017-2018) and a visiting scholar in the Centre for Conflict Resolution of International Conflicts at the University of Copenhagen (2014), https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13523260.2020.1866845. //parip
A dual-use security dilemma occurs when actors face an opponent that wields technologies with both civil and military/harmful applications. In developing this concept of the dual-use security dilemma, I build on traditional and constructivist approaches to security. Following traditional security scholars, I suggest that uncertainty shapes actors’ behavior and argue that we can extend the concept of security dilemma to capture the dynamics around the threat of dual-use technologies. However, these uncertainties, and actors’ responses, are also socially constructed and shaped by knowledge and social understandings. From a traditional security perspective, the dual-use security dilemma extends the dynamics of policy makers’ fears around an opponent’s defensive or offensive intentions to include the fear of the potentially harmful civil technologies. Policy makers are uncertain whether the opponents have harmful intentions in using the technology. But the potential of their using or adapting the technology for harmful purposes, even over the long term, creates insecurity and may spur policy makers to take measures to address the threat. Similar to the traditional security dilemma, these measures can influence an opponent’s behavior, leading it to acquire military means or even to make military use of the dual-use technology. Furthermore, and also like the traditional security dilemma, these dynamics may spiral, aggravating the actors’ security. Even actors whose aim was to develop technology solely for civil purposes may find themselves in an arms race or a costly situation. While militarily arming a civilian project can be very expensive (for both sides), failing to respond to a military project because of its civilian characteristics can also be very costly. From a constructivist approach, the dilemma is shaped by how the insecurity is constructed. Insecurity is not given, but rather is socially produced through actors calling attention to certain issues and mobilizing support to address them. Moreover, how a technology is applied—for peaceful or military purposes—is also socially determined. This means a technology’s dual-usage is influenced not only by its technical characteristics, but also by international norms, by how it is conceived, and by how knowledge is mediated by socio-scientific agents. Seeing a technology as dual-use allows an actor to construct it as a(n) (existential) threat, even if the technology is developed for civil purposes. The dilemma, then, is whether or not to securitize. While securitizing a potential challenge carries the advantage of preparing for a threat and mobilizing support for certain policy measures, it can also contribute to a spiral insecurity dynamic. Once a technology has been acknowledged as dual-use, an enunciator can take advantage of the accompanying uncertainty of how the technology will be used. They can securitize an opponent's dual-use technology to justify taking extraordinary measures to address it—regardless of the opponent’s intentions around developing the technology’s military/harmful applications. Furthermore, the very act of securitizing an opponent’s technology without taking any extraordinary measures—can alarm an opponent, who then initiates a securitizing reaction. All these may result in a securitizing chain reaction that decreases both actors’ security.