Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Tech innovation and dominance isn’t a neutral tool, but is an end and object of US security politics to secure the US’s self-image – the instrumentalization thesis is ahistorical and can’t explain the form of US innovation policies

McCarthy, 2021

(Daniel R., Senior Lecturer in International Relations at the University of Melbourne, “Imagining the security of innovation: technological innovation, national security, and the American way of life,” Critical Studies on Security, Vol. 9, Iss. 3, 2021, pp. 196-211, https://doi.org/10.1080/21624887.2021.1934640, accessed 7/2/2022, ZW)

Technological innovation is generically viewed in security studies in an instrumental fashion, as a means to the end of national power and, thus, national security (Mearsheimer 2001, 62; Taylor, C., 2004, 602; cf. Kennedy and Lim 2018). An instrumental understanding of technological innovation presents innovation as context-transcendent and ahistorical. Essentializing innovation in these terms makes it difficult to understand how and why actually existing state innovation policies take a specific form and, in turn, how certain forms of technological innovation become ends in themselves and objects of security politics.

Critical security studies and critical international relations theory, drawing on the theoretical resources of Science and Technology Studies (STS), has begun to question this apolitical view of the practice of technological innovation (Bourne, Johnson and Lisle 2018; Bourne 2016; Lisle 2018). Through this work a picture of innovation emerges as always political, as central to the making and remaking of the state and its security politics. This article builds on this shared theoretical impulse through engagement with the Socio-Technical Imaginaries (STI) framework developed by Sheila Jasanoff and collaborators, whose work has been relatively neglected in International Relations (IR) to date (Jasanoff and Sang-Hyn 2009; Jasanoff and Kim 2013, 2015; Chenou 2019; McCarthy 2021). STI analyses common-sense socio-technical imaginaries, understood as encompassing world views. These are world-making, informing logics of practical action, their materialisation in technological infrastructures, and the recreation of specific forms of political order. Imaginaries are pre-theoretical, lacking the reflexivity of theory proper. As a result, they are informed by cultural tropes, myths and narratives, including, as recent work on cybersecurity has demonstrated, those found in popular culture (Dunn Cavelty 2019). Viewed in these terms, technological innovation, its security, and its place in modernity, is recast. Far from being a straightforward expression of instrumental reason, technological innovation is a politically and culturally contested process through which world order is created and maintained.

Answering the question of why a specific form of technological innovation is an object of security in US national security policy, this article argues that the United States pursues the national security of technological innovation in order to secure its ‘way of life’ as disclosed by its socio-technical imaginaries. A ‘way of life’ is broader than national identity – it is a ‘combination of patterns of thought and action that, as it becomes habitual and institutionalized, defines the thrust and character of a culture and society’ (Williams 1980, 12). Or, in Grove’s (2020, 2) more succinct phrase, these are ‘ways of being in the world’. In concrete terms, the US imaginaries detailed below portray market-led innovation as a means to the end of classic national security goals; technological innovation will not occur unless it is enabled by market-based incentives. Alongside this, the American policy narratives assert that market-led technological innovation enables material practices which express the American national identity. For heuristic purposes, then, we can separate these world-views into two elements, a causal account of how technological innovation happens, including the relationship between different actors, institutions, and the material incentives they create, and a normative evaluation of these practices and the threats to them (Taylor. C., 2004, 24–25). Technological innovation encapsulates the spirit of the American character, with threats to intellectual property rights emerging as a threat to America itself.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.