Be skeptical of every aff claims their threats are real – their rhetorical acts are only meant to deepen the ruse of securitization. Skepticism makes the entire system crumble.
Ojeda, 22 – Michelle Domenica Maffei Ojeda is a master’s degree candidate in Research in International Relations with mention in Security and Human Rights, [“Political Discourse Analysis over the Securitization Discourse from the US towards Venezuela: The Case of Obama and Trump (2015-2020)”, Latin American Faculty of Social Sciences, FLACSO Ecuador Department of International Studies and Communication, April 2022, https://repositorio.flacsoandes.edu.ec/bitstream/10469/18466/2/TFLACSO-2022MDMO.pdf]RA
The pivotal point over securitization is that speeches with a receptive audience create a threat. The more an idea is accepted by the audience, it becomes a reality. On the same note, for the process of securitization to work properly, it requires a political actor, which in this case is Obama and Trump along with an audience that will take their words as legitimate. According to Buzan “unless an idea is widely held, it cannot count as part of the idea of the state” (1983, 53). Language to work properly, or any speech act, it requires a teleological classification, what is good and what is bad, and for it to be accepted by the audience/society. Language itself is violent and requires a binary logic to outline the limitations of its own fields by excluding, when there is exclusion- the gray areas in the concept do not interrelate- then the more difficult is to forget or re-arrange the core block of an idea. Language is built in a way that the more you use an object as a threat, the audience will eventually believe it and get in sync. The analysis of threat construction from the securitization theory, states that the perception of threat is not something exogenous. Rather is constructed by widely accepted ideas from the collectivity, the audience, also known as the “us”. A threat is not physical or tangible but rather represent an existential danger to the construction of the “us” . It is everything that can categorically be foreign in our identity creeds. We must take into account that at the core, national security in the securitization theory is also linked with the notion of securitizing oneself from outside and domestic threats for survival. Hence, the political elite that invokes “securitization” will also inherently mention the consequences of taking no response at all, increasing fear through the possible weakening of state foundations/institutions, which is an extension of the nation and of individuals. The foundation to understand a threat is the construction of the ‘us’ versus the antagonist ‘other’, both are mutually sustaining and not excluded. This mutual constitution of language can be seen through the fact that Venezuela and the EE.UU. are antagonist and still have deep economic ties and be highly interdependent (Bonfili 2010).