Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Cybersecurity threats are overblown and have more to do with creating the perception of a threat than the harm of the attack itself.

Fouad 19 – Noran Shafik Fouad is a Postdoctoral Research Associate, Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford, [“The Peculiarities of Securitising Cyberspace: A Multi-Actor Analysis of the Construction of Cyber Threats in the US (2003-2016)”, University of Sussex, Brighton, UK, 2019]RA

The nature of the cyber threat: between existentiality and urgency

Unlike other security sectors, cybersecurity threats are always perceived in the form of attacks, or hostile, purposeful, and deliberate actions by an enemy/adversary against the referent object(s). While this attack logic can still be used occasionally in all sectors, it is the dominant one in cybersecurity. All cyber operations, even the ‘defensive’, involve the use of malware by an actor to gain unauthorised access into the target’s system. A vulnerability in a system is not threatening per se if not exploited, and this exploitation requires an adversary’s or another party’s involvement. Although the resemblances with the military sector here are high, one more aspect makes cybersecurity more distinctive: the question of existentiality. According to the securitisation theory, the defining feature of security is the idea of existentiality; i.e. security is concerned with the survival of a certain referent object(s), which justifies the calls for urgent responses. In cybersecurity, despite the existence of existential discourses, the existentiality assumption is not as straightforward as it is in other sectors for multiple reasons. Firstly, the majority of cyber attacks that are seen as the most serious in history were neither objectively existential from a technical viewpoint, nor portrayed as such by the concerned actors. Stealing military, commercial, or personal information can hardly affect the survival of the state, the private sector, or any individual. Similarly, denying customers/citizens access to certain services through denial of service attacks (DOS) does not pose an existential threat to anyone. This does not mean that cyber threats cannot be hyped, exaggerated, or presented in urgent terms, since all those qualities are not essentially linked to existentiality. Secondly, the indirect nature of the majority of cyber attacks and the non-physicality of their consequences, although does not undermine their seriousness and urgency, acts as an impeding rather than a facilitating condition to the existentiality assumption. The empirical analysis also proves that existentiality is not the only reason for threats to register in the cybersecurity debate and that it is not a precondition for perceived urgency. Generally, cybersecurity is marked by different understandings of disruptive and destructive implications of cyber threats, and all invoke a certain level of urgency. The majority of discourses emphasise these ‘disruptive’ implications, including huge financial losses that can slow down the economy, loss of productivity and global competitiveness, customers’ loss of confidence in the information infrastructure, etc. Though not portrayed in ‘survival’ terms, these disruptive implications are still perceived as immanent, urgent, and as serious threats to national security. 3.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.