Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Realism is the only way to ensure US and NATO security – Countries will not stop in pursuit of cyberattacks on a military scale.

Daricili and Celik 21 (A. Burak Daricili, Case Officer in the Department of Intelligence and Security; Soner Celik, of Suleymen Demirel University, “National Security 2.0: The Cyber Security of Critical Infrastructure,” Perceptions: Journal of International Affairs. https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/2181981) //AA

Intellectuals such as Thomas Hobbes, Niccolò Machiavelli and Jean-Jacques Rousseau had a pessimistic perspective that can be applied to the ways in which national security needs to be understood. Those intellectuals accepted the international system as an area where states continuously fight with each other to pursue their own selfish interests. For this reason, it is impossible to establish universal peace, as the Idealists desire. This line of reasoning is accepted by Realists such as Carr and Hans Morgenthau; in their view, the only way to prevent a state from becoming a hegemon in the international system, where there is a constant conflict of interests among states, is for states to balance each other’s power.11 The pessimistic viewpoint of classical Realists is accepted by neo-realists such as Kenneth Waltz and John Mearsheimer, according to whom security or insecurity is a result of the anarchic nature of the international system on a large scale. Therefore, international policy will continuously sustain a tendency to violence.12 The Realist political approach accepts states as the main actors of the international system; since the interests of each country differ from each other, there is always the possibility of war, and some kind of conflict or fighting is inevitable. The Realist approach defines the international system as anarchic, and characterizes international policy as a power struggle in which security is the main agenda item in the realm of international relations. In this respect, the security concept for Realist theoreticians is discussed through “insecurity” in general terms, and this theoretic approach is explained via themes of power, threat and insecurity. Cyberspace-based developments, today, propose new approaches to states’ threat, security and deterrence agendas. Some states have even begun to see cyber attack and cyber conflict as important methods of engaging in strategic defense and inflicting damage on their opponents. Developments in cyberspace bring along new security risks; the importance of removing these risks has thus also increased, compelling states to develop strategies to address this issue. For Realist theorists, this makes the international system even more uncertain and anarchic than before, especially given that cyber attacks can be caused not merely by states but by individuals.13 In Realist terms, the diversification of risks to cyberspace resources, and the inability to determine the source of these risks, deepens the anarchic structure of the international system. A cyberspace attacker can hide his or her identity by using various forms of crypto software and programs. The attacker can even conduct a “false flag”14 operation, making it appear that the source of the cyber attack is another state or a state-sponsored hacker group by using similar software. All of these circumstances deepen the insecurity of the international system and reinforce the mutual distrust between states. Power struggle and competition in the international system have expanded into a new dimension thanks to internet-based developments. Many states have used these technologies as an opportunity to develop their hard power. Improving military power with the help of cyber-based technology and skill has become an important goal for these states. Allocating budgets, making investments, training experts and establishing cyber military commands in tandem with conventional army development are now essential for states in order to reach a powerful attack and defense capacity in cyberspace.15 All of these developments contribute to what Realists call the “security dilemma,” a phenomenon whereby “many of the instruments that are used by a state to increase its security decrease the security of others.”16 And it is ongoing. When one state makes a military investment or takes a military measure, this is taken as a threat by another state, which then applies similar measures, which in turn are interpreted by other states as a threat. The threat perceptions of states vis-à-vis one another escalate, in some cases leading to an armament race with mutual measures taken back and forth.17 Based on the security dilemma concept, states evaluate international relations as a zero-sum game, and plan their behavior patterns in the international system based on the assumption of relative earnings. They also avoid cooperation by asking the question, “who will benefit more?” instead of, “how can we both profit?” As indicated above, the Realist approach adopts a competitive and confrontational security perspective on the axis of anarchy. Given the rigidity of this perspective, the limitations and difficulties of cooperation in the Realist paradigm come into prominence. Because the structure of the international system is anarchic, according to this approach, this insecure environment prevents states from cooperating in the long term,18 a situation exacerbated by the anonymous structure of cyberspace and its accompanying uncertainties, which diversify and deepen risks. Concerning all these evaluations, the mentality that has started to gain credence recently is that critical infrastructure is an inseparable part of a state’s cybersecurity and thus its cybersecurity strategies. This perspective is clearly emphasized in the national cybersecurity documents of many states. For example, Turkey’s National Cyber Security Strategy (2020–2023) Document states, “Cybersecurity is an inseparable part of national security. Providing national security in an absolute manner depends on achieving [our] goals in the cybersecurity field.”19 As mentioned above, the security of critical infrastructure and information systems that are mostly managed by internet technologies has become vital to the security of any state. States, now, are aware that cyber attacks targeting critical structures can be a serious threat, and that such attacks can negatively affect their political, economic and military security.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.