Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The DoS is comparatively better for international diplomacy

Lord 8- president and CEO of IREX, an independent nonprofit organization dedicated to building a more just, prosperous, and inclusive world by empowering youth, cultivating leaders, strengthening institutions, and extending access to quality education and information (Kristin, “The State Department, Not the Pentagon, Should Lead America’s Public Diplomacy Efforts,” Brookings, 10-29-08, Accessed Online at https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/the-state-department-not-the-pentagon-should-lead-americas-public-diplomacy-efforts/, Accessed Online on 7-4-22)

In most circumstances, the Department of Defense (DoD) should not serve as the most visible face of the United States overseas. This is particularly true in areas where the public feels threatened by American power.

The Middle East is one area where polls show distrust of American motives and concern that America seeks to dominate the region militarily. Indeed, according to a Pew Global Attitudes Project survey taken last year, 64 percent of Turks – citizens of a NATO ally – see the United States as the greatest threat to their country in the future. Civilians, including those who do not work for government agencies, are the best conduits for building trust with wary publics.

Civilians should not just be the public face of communications. They should also set strategy and tactics that advance American foreign policy interests, in close cooperation with defense officials and military commanders. This is officially the role of the State Department, our nation’s lead agency in making and implementing foreign policy. Yet, informally, resources drive outcomes, and the Pentagon has most of the money.

Consider this: The $100 million annual price tag of the initiative described above is just one element of the Pentagon’s communication efforts in one country. Yet, it is equivalent to roughly one-eighth of the State Department’s entire public diplomacy budget for the entire world.

Perhaps the DoD’s new Iraq activities deserve this level of prominence – but it is unlikely that a government-wide discussion of priorities ever took place. Whereas $100 million per year is big money for public diplomats, it is small change for the military, which spends $434 million per day in Iraq.

The State Department, meanwhile, must meet a host of pressing concerns ranging from short-term communication needs to long-term educational exchanges with about $800 million per year.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.