Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

EU cred is at stake.

Lahodynsky 20 (Otmar Lahodynsky, former president of the Association of European journalists. The EU’s credibility is at stake, New Europe, 11/20/20, https://www.neweurope.eu/article/the-eus-credibility-is-at-stake/) – JL

In July, after a four-day marathon summit in Brussels, there was agreement on the EU budget for 2021-2027 and a recovery fund for the EU’s 27 members following the COVID-19 crisis. Together, almost €2 trillion have been reserved for this purpose. The €750 billion corona aid package is intended to help those countries that have been the most affected by the disease, including as Italy, Spain and France, but also the other Member States as they will need to rebuild their economies. At the EU summit, a typical Brussels-style compromise was reached – each head of government presented themself as a winner at home if they will receive a lot of money for economic recovery. It was then that the so-called “frugal four” – Denmark, the Netherlands, Austria and Sweden (plus Finland) – forced a reduction in the number of grants in exchange for an increase in the share of loans and a cut in their membership fees. The heads of Poland and Hungary also celebrated at home after the successfully de-linked their access to EU funding from their records on the rule of law. Subsequently, however, the other EU states introduced this clause by a clear majority. The Poles and Hungarians felt pressured and they vetoed the seven-year EU budget, which requires unanimity despite the fact that they were not bothered that they had previously approved it. In his explanatory statement, Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki railed against an “attack on Polish sovereignty” and adding that the EU was no longer the same as when Poland had joined the bloc in 2004, a generation after the end of Communism. Morawiecki said the Polish economy was so strong that it no longer needed any subsidies from Brussels (more than €12 billion each year). Morawiecki said that Poles were even considering an EU withdrawal along the lines of Brexit. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, Brussels’ bête noire, went even further. In his view, the EU is acting like the Soviet Union once did. It wants to blackmail Hungary and force it to accept Middle Eastern refugees. In the future, Orban added, the European Commission would have the power to meddle in the internal politics of all of the Member States, as it sees fit. Orban also emphasized that the EU’s previous accusations against Hungary were all unfounded and that the concept of the rule of law was not precisely or universally defined. The reality is that these core concepts of the bloc were long-ago enshrined in the EU treaties and in Europe’s charter of fundamental rights. Conditions for EU accession were already laid down in the 1993 Copenhagen criteria and include the stability of institutions, democracy, the rule of law, respect for human rights and respect and protection of minorities. The Commission has, for too long, turned a blind eye to the transgressions of the nationalistic populists in Poland, Hungary and other Eastern European countries. The isolated attempts to bring about punitive proceedings under Article 7 of the EU Treaty did not act as a deterrent, because sanctions were not imposed. For this reason, the governments of Hungary and Poland mutually helped each other. But now the basic principles of the EU, above all the rule of law, are being put to the test. When Brussels collectively raises billions of euros for emergency aid against the pandemic for the first time through common debts, it must be ensured that this money is spent correctly. The EU also owes this to its taxpayers. In Hungary, Orban’s confidants and his family have collected a lot more than €5 billion in subsidies from Brussels every year, mainly through agricultural subsidies. The European Council in a new report this week criticized Hungary for not fighting against corruption. In an ironic echo of Hungary’s totalitarian Communist past, nearly all of Hungary’s independent or critical media have been brought into line or closed down and the scientific community and cultural institutions are also under Orban’s control. In Poland, the independence of the judiciary was dangerously undermined on several occasions. Some cities have established their own “LGTB-free zones” and, with the support of Poland’s notoriously arch-conservative branch of the Catholic Church, a ban on abortion was imposed recently with only a few exceptions. The EU must protect the rule of law and fundamental European values more strongly than before for another reason. If these are violated without consequences, how can Europe require new candidate countries to respect these values? A way out of the stalemate seems difficult. The European Parliament has made it clear that it will not accept any amendments to the draft. “These nationalistic, populist positions and unanimity are the grave-diggers of the EU,” said Othmar Karas, the Vice-President of the European Parliament who asked for the exclusion of Orban’s Fidesz-party from the European People’s Party. Fortunately, the budget for 2021 has already been adopted. It contains innovations, including more money for future areas such as digitalization and climate protection. If Poland and Hungary retain their veto, this budget could be prolonged annually. The €750 billion COVID aid package could possibly be decoupled from the EU budget. In that case, such support through joint borrowing could only be decided for 24 countries – without Hungary, Poland and Slovenia. It is a more laborious path, but possibly the only one, as the EU’s credibility as a global player is at stake.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.