Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Gatekeeping DA – the perm is white respectability politics – they tokenize anti-racist critique while maintaining the form of disciplinary white IR while evading accountability but centering blackness thru refusing white epistemology solves

Abu-Bakare 22 – lecturer in the politics of race and decolonial studies at the University of Liverpool and a Visiting Fellow at the University of the University of South Wales’ International Centre for Policing and Security, PhD in International Politics at Aberystwyth University [Amal, “Your Work is Not International Relations,” Alternatives: Global, Local, Political, First Published 3/3/2022, https://doi.org/10.1177/03043754221076965, DKP]

The aim of this essay is to use my individual experience as an entry point for speaking to a structural pattern in IR scholarship. Here, I explore how observing the scholastic process of connecting disciplinary boundaries to real political lines demarcates an ongoing concern with how some academics pursue a monopoly on understandings of ‘the international’, treating its porous semi-arbitrary boundaries as though they define the political issues that traverse them (Conway, 2021). Some have described this monopoly as a form of methodological disciplinarity, a practice where research becomes restricted within disciplinary borders because of scholastic endeavours to keep the discipline pure. In this process, IR gatekeepers come to reject IR’s existence as a discipline that exists between fields, being focused on metaphorically manning the academic watchtower. By being busy policing what is and what is not a global issue, these same intellectuals miss key opportunities for innovative knowledge production concerning the international. As Annika Olsson (2015: 47) observes, ‘scholars of all kinds need to cross the borders of their disciplines more often’ if they are to bring new knowledge home. Vitalis concurs in his own exploration of the birth of American IR, where he writes that ‘the boundaries of international relations theory and in particular work in security […] remain open and ripe for infiltration’(2015:180). We indeed need to challenge ‘the bodies and borders of literature’ if we are ever to truly understand the structural nature of inequities in knowledge sharing in international studies (Olsson, 2015: 47).

On the question of whose bodies? Importantly, in the opening quote, it appears that the editors responding to my article felt that their contributing authors had to tick several boxes on their checklist. Not just to earn the right to exist within the purview of the journal but also to be considered international studies. My concern lies with how these editors seem disconcerted by how broadly their mandate may have been conceived instead of welcoming such breadth in conceptualisation. In the arena of IR, post-structural scholars have long since argued that the boundary between the international and domestic is insecure. Using the writings of Foucault, Derrida, Lacan and Žižek, Edkins (1999), for example, famously contested the technical arrangements that erroneously restricted the notion of the international subject when politics was presented as being a subsystem of social order instead of being seen as a mirror of a society’s own forgotten foundation – cutting off human beings from their sense of self. Others such as Charbonneau and Cox (2010: 14), in the context of foreign policy analysis, write how it is in locally situated security practices that scholars often find spaces where vital ‘elements of state power and global order are produced and reproduced’. So, why were the editors I quoted uncomfortable in the case of another break with the international–domestic divide prompted on the basis of a race-orientated tradition? A problem is that their anxiety and discomfort with a lack of perimeters being erected in this specific instance may possibly have been grounded in a particular epistemic genealogy where having a monopoly on how the international is conceived also constituted a form of racial domination. Allowing an analytical radicalism to be applied to IR problems only so far as they do not cross Eurocentric-white boundaries for what still constitutes intellectual respectability.

As a discipline, IR has historically provided numerous sources of intellectual rationale to justify only certain conceptions of the international which foreground norms of white subjectivity, and that in turn epistemically constrain the boundaries of political imagination within the discipline. This is largely as a result of IR’s origin, as a policy science devised to resolve dilemmas ‘facing the white Western powers’ because of colonial administration (Anievas, Manchanda and Shilliam, 2015: 2). IR’s academic conventions more often than not still prompt recognition of how colonial histories matter yet are muted in the politics of the present. This is so in how these conventions still force the centre of non-Western and non-white people’s worlds to exist at the margins of the world(s) European imperialists endeavoured to create (Shilliam, 2021). In this regard, calling out racial attitudes to IR expertise necessitates drawing attention to how lines are drawn between intellectuals who are accused of dabbling in ‘selective colonial historiography for “political” purposes’, and those who are actually seen as ‘bona fide’ in international studies on the basis of the way they choose to assess what is global (Stoler, 2011:137). The public performance of solidarity by scholastic institutions appearing to support scholars that raise the issue of anti-imperial perspectives, all while still preventing the professional dispersal of their knowledge behind the scenes is indicative of the wage of white supremacy. This is so in how these IR gatekeepers enable perpetrators of intellectual tokenism to evade detection and accountability for their part in furthering imperialist ways of knowing the issues that plague the world populations. These same actors, counterintuitively, directly ensure that a limited understanding about how different populations experience world politics prevails.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.