Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Footnoting DA – it’s about starting points – you can’t add black scholarship and stir

Hawthorne and Heitz 18 – *Chair of the Black Geographies Specialty Group of the American Association of Geographers, Assistant Professor of Sociology at UC-Santa Cruz, PhD in Geography at UC Berkeley, MPA at Brown, BA in International Relations and Africana Studies at Brown, ** PhD Student in Human Geography, UC Berkeley [Camilla, Kaily, “A seat at the table? Reflections on Black geographies and the limits of dialogue,” 2018, DKP]

It is impossible to engage with the politics of dialogue without first situating ourselves—after all, these are fundamentally questions of power and access. I (Camilla) am a first-generation university student and the first in my immediate family to pursue a graduate degree. As a Black woman geographer, I must continuously reckon with the fact that the university—and the discipline of geography itself—was not made for me. Historically, the university has been a site wherein the subjugation of women and people of color has been articulated and legitimated. Still, I was drawn to human geography because it appeared to be a capacious, interdisciplinary field with productively porous boundaries. In other words, geography seemed to welcome, rather than strictly regulate, theoretical and methodological dialogue between disciplines. But when I began my PhD program, I experienced a distinct sense of alienation as I attempted to do research that seemed marginal to geography (specifically, understanding how Black youth in Italy craft a sense of place that challenges the symbolic and material boundaries of Europeanness and Italianness). I was alarmed that the vocabulary and rich canon shaped by my background in Africana studies (for instance, theories of diaspora, or the works of scholars such as Paul Gilroy and Sylvia Wynter) were not always recognized as ‘formally’ geographical, even though the issues they addressed were fundamentally about space, place, and power. I was similarly alarmed by the fact that, in a discipline whose history is so closely tied to the violent histories of colonialism and racism, race remained a relatively insignificant category in contemporary geography, a ‘superstructural’ embellishment atop the ‘material’, clanking gears of capitalism. The questions that animated my research and the intellectual genealogies I wanted to draw upon, were deeply spatial but seemedillegible to geography. They were, in other words, beyond dialogue.

As a Black woman, I (Kaily) can recall being taught from a very early age not to fight back. When I mouthed off, I was told to sit down and quite literally to shut up. ‘Black’ and ‘girl’ were thrown in my face as insults, justifications for my silence. Insecure in my body, I was also insecure in place, as I constantly moved around the country. Feeling powerless to do much to tangibly or markedly interface with the city streets or Midwestern fields in which I grew up, I found myself drawn to art and photography as some of the few ways I could dialogically assert the power of my body and represent it assuredly in place. Having utilized this embodied knowledge in my thesis research, my advisor proposed that I look into geography programs for my PhD. I found it to be a thrilling and expansive field that had the capacity to engage the language of visual representation and its materialization in structures of race, class, and environment. Like Camilla, my enthusiasm quickly hardened into exasperation when I found that theories of race and gender in geography were limited to one week each in most first-year curricula. I was, and still am, seeking to find the middle ground between the extensive attention Black studies scholars have paid to representations of race, and geographical scholarship on how place is epistemologically formed. It is time that geographers utilized the interdisciplinary nature of their field to widen dialogue formerly limited by structural inequalities.

As Rose-Redwood et al. (2018) rightly argue, certain voices have been systematically excluded from the physical and metaphorical spaces of dialogue within the field of human geography. The marginalization of Black geographic scholarship within the discipline cannot be understood separately from the marginalization of Black scholars at all levels within geography. This means that the academy can itself be a site of violence that regulates who can participate in scholarly dialogue. But, at the same time, we want to argue that the project of Black Geographies is more than simply a project of ‘add Black people and stir’. It is about moving beyond a liberal politics of superficial and provisional inclusion to think seriously about which voices, intellectual genealogies, and traditions of thought are deemed sufficiently canonical or scholarly—and why.

Claims to dialogue within human geography, and the academy writ large, are frequently invoked to obscure a lack of engagement with noncanonical scholarship. Yet we are still convinced that geography has important things to offer our understanding of blackness, and vice versa—that centering blackness can actually tell us important things about space and place, about power and the politics of resistance. The Black Geographies Symposium, for instance, was centered on a shared understanding of blackness as a fundamentally spatial relation, of space as profoundly racialized, and of the history of geography as entangled with racism, colonialism, and enslavement. What would it mean, for instance, if geographers were to read Marx on the factory alongside W.E.B. Du Bois and C.L.R. James on the plantation, or Jamaica Kincaid alongside Doreen Massey on relational understandings of place? A Black geographical scholarly praxis entails a willingness to subvert arborescent models of intellectual lineage in favor of queerings, rhizomes, undercommons (Harney and Moten, 2013), provincializations, or even the Sankofa (Benjamin, 2013). These are, in other words, nonhierarchical and nonlinear modes of study that can attend to the complex geographical itineraries and interconnected struggles that continue to shape our understandings of the relations of capitalism, racism, and sexism that structure the modern world.

Perhaps, then, we should be striving for something more radical than dialogue. Rose-Redwood et al. (2018) point toward the possibilities of dialogue as embodied action; but what if we instead take liberatory knowledges as the point of departure, rather than ‘democratic’ dialogue or abject embodiment? In her keynote presentation at the Black Geographies symposium, Katherine McKittrick suggested that scholarly dialogue necessarily invokes the materiality of humanness in both body and place:

‘The materiality of intellectual inquiry, the ideas we share, the counsel we give each other, is an ongoing referential conversation about Black humanity. [ ...] The materiality of intellectual inquiry, the ideas we share, is a referential conversation that begins from Black humanness’.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.