Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their attempt to model China’s desires is connected to a global process of control through modulating China’s tech development coalesces imperial violence

Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19. Nick Dyer-Witheford is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at University of Western Ontario and Svitlana Matviyenko is an Assistant Professor of Critical Media Analysis in the School of Communication. “Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism.” March 2019.

This is not the place for a detailed examination of the political economy of "postsocialist" nations (Lane 2014). In the USSR, the orgy of privatization and the chaos of shocktherapy marketization after 1991 have been followed under Putin by a new period of nationalization, in which oligarchic capitalists operate under supervision of, and overlap with, state elites in a context of market exchange (Worth 2005; Pirani 2010; Dzarasov 2014; Sakwa 2014). In the more complex case of the People's Republic of China, the party apparatus has maintained control of some "commanding heights" of the economy, even as other domains are handed over to private ownership, including both foreign and domestic investors. Some commentators see China's arrangements as tantamount to full subsumption with the world market (Li 2009; HartLandsberg 2013); others consider that a "left turn" from within the party apparatus could reestablish a socialist project (Amin 2013). At the moment, the latter possibility seems remote. In Russia, China, and other postsocialist countries, the wage organizes production, the responsibilities of the state for provision of public services have typically been diminished, and there are vast income gulfs between workers in and owners of the means of production. Corruption is often rife. Political elites are either identical with, entangled in, or dependent on capital ownership, and although these elites must in various ways manage, mobilize, and hegemonize public opinion, their fractions define the agenda of policy decisions, and perhaps especially foreign policy decisions. Thus discussions of international relations in terms of the intentions or desires of "China" or "Russia" - as, of course, of the "United States," "Canada," "Ukraine," "Saudi Arabia," or any other capitalist nation - must be understood as shorthand metonymic mystification of ruling-class power. Cyberwar has therefore emerged as a topic of global concern at a moment when the teleological certainties of Marxism seem broken or reduced to cruel caricature. This is not a coincidence. As we will argue, the emergence of cybernetics from the military-industrial complex of the United States at the end of the Second Word War was an important part of that nation's ascent as a new imperial leader for the capitalist system. Computers and networks, both in their military and economic applications, played an important role in eventual U.S. victory over the USSR in the Cold War. And their extension into electronic commodities, industrial automation, supply-chain logistics, and financial trading was a crucial part of the globalization in which a reinvigorated capitalism from 1989 on disseminated itself around the planet, under the shelter of the global hegemon's cruise missiles, smart weapons, and satellite intelligence. This armed pacification of a world market has, however, not had the finality many expected. Rather, it has generated new wars, of two major types, both misnamed and ill defined but each a consequence of capital's global triumph over its socialist opponents. The "war on terror" is, of course, the conventional and ideologically laden name for the protracted sequence of conflicts set in motion when mujahideen, armed and financed by the United States and its Saudi Arabian ally to fight the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, turned on its imperial patron with the destruction of the World Trade Center in 2001. These conflicts, centered on the Middle East but radiating across the planet, include the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan; world-distributed terrorist attacks; and counterterrorist operations across Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Nigeria, the Philippines, Mali, Libya, and many other theaters. If the "war on terror" is sometimes colloquially used to include the U.S. invasion of Iraq, this craven acceptance of the spurious rationalizations offered by the Bush administration could be only retroactively justified, as U.S. occupation generated first both Sunni and Shia insurgency and later, in its aftermath, the rise of ISIS. This so-called war on terror interpenetrates other regional conflicts, such as those in Kashmir between India and Pakistan, Russian actions in Chechnya, and Saudi Arabia's intensifying clashes with Iran in Yemen and elsewhere, and also overlaps with Israel's constant operations against Palestinians, wars with neighbors, and determination to maintain its regional monopoly of nuclear weapons. It is not our aim here to map the noxious vectors of the "war on terror," only to highlight how its mutating fronts have been a bleeding edge for the development and use of cyberweaponry, in counterinsurgency operations, domestic surveillance, and digital strikes and sabotage against nuclear weapons facilities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.