Cyber warfare is a product of racial capitalisms unconscious – the root cause is violence shaped by inter-capitalist rivalries that make war inevitable – but it also is a source for revolutionary disruptions through a “cyber war on cyber war” that short-circuits capitals monopoly on violence
Dyer-Witherford and Mtviyenko 17 – Nick Dyer-Witheford is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at University of Western Ontario and Svitlana Matviyenko is an Assistant Professor of Critical Media Analysis in the School of Communication [Nick, Svitlana, “Cyber-War and Contemporary Marxism,” 2017, DKP]
Cyber-war could, in theory be part of a contemporary revolutionary war position which might include development militant hacking to sabotage and paralyse corporate operations, recovering the worker power lost by the (cybernetic) diminishment of the power of the mass strike, etc, or disrupting the financial sector. More loosely, as we have already mentioned the last decades of seen some successes in cyber-organizing of occupations, demonstrations and riots, and one could imagine this process intensifying in future crises. However, there are problems in particular to applying cyber-war to revolutionary ends. As Hassan (2013), Dyer-Witheford (2015) and others have argued, there is a misfit between the speed and secrecy of cyber-war practices and the slower and social logic that, in the long term, form radically emancipatory subjects and movements: reliance on cyber-organizing probably account for some of the "up like a rocket, down like a stick" aspect of the 2011 occupations. Moreover, despite hacker romanticism, there is a persisting imbalance of power between state and no-state forces even in the digital realm (Healey 2013), and the new vulnerability of social movements to surveillance cyber-crackdowns seriously jeopardises all sorts of cyber-organizing hacktivism. To assess the future possibilities of revolutionary cyber-war therefore requires an overall assessment of the diverse factors at play in the emergence of cyber-war as a feature of contemporary capitalism, a task to which we now turn.
3. Cyber-War and the capitalist unconscious
Cyber war emerges from and is shaped by the interaction of inter-capitalist rivalries, class war, technological revolutions and both progressive and reactionary social movements, producing an extremely complex diagram. What we might call the horizontal axis of inter-state conflicts, with which many cyber war accounts begin, has to be seen in relation to a vertical axis that pits these same rival states against a seething mass of (often contradictory) digitized resistance movements (many of which are supported or co-opted by inter-state rivalries in various proxy wars), with both horizontal and vertical dynamics arising from, and feeding into, a common origin-point in capitalism's most recent technological revolution. These different vectors interact to create a series of zigzagging, diagonal or swerving alignments whose chaotic tendencies are enhanced by the decentralization, opacity and velocity of networked interaction.
This complex pattern of conflicts can be seen as a manifestation of global capitalism's "unconscious" (Tom sic 2016; Jameson 1991). By this we mean that cyber-war is symptomatic of features of the world-market unacknowledged in the neoliberal discourse of "globalization", namely the profound aggression and destructiveness intrinsic to an order predicated on privatized competition. While neoliberalism of course not only recognises but enthusiastically celebrates competition and its associated "disruptions" and "creative destruction" as a spur to innovation and wealth creation, its official message is that ultimately the "invisible hand" of the market anneals this into the greater good of optimal resource allocation. What is denied is the possibility that this competitive agonistic system might explode into non-creative destruction, and that the ultimate "disruption" is to be found in the horror of war. Cyber-war is a secretive but increasingly present irruption of this possibility, a partially contained yet intensifying expression of the world market's disintegrative tendencies. As aspects of the opaque and undeclared but deeply penetrative refashioning of social subjects by cyber-war we include the following points:
* Cyber-war is "crepuscular" (Virilio 2002). Cyber-war as neither simply a fabrication of cyber-security experts (Blunden & Cheung 2013; Rid 2013) nor the imminent equivalent of nuclear war, as some of those experts suggest (Clark 2011). It belongs rather neither war nor peace, as form of shadow hostility that is compatible with and cross cuts officially civil relations between states (e.g. US relations with Russia and China) and the outbreak of kinetic conflicts (Syria, Ukraine). It is neither identical to nor separate from either conventional war or peace time signals intelligence operations, but is rather the persistent background noise or "ceiling" (2013) of capital's new cold (and hot) wars, and its endemic class wars.
■ Cyber-war is mystifying. It is well recognized that cyber-war operations pose an "attribution problem" because of the tendency to "obliterate proof" (Filiol 2011) of its perpetrators. Although many of these attribution problems are convincingly solved, sometimes surprisingly quickly (Hansen 2013), they nevertheless invest questions of war and peace, security and risk with a deep murkiness and proliferating anxieties and paranoia.
Cyber-war as marketized (or privatized) war-in which the state's "monopoly of violence" is reinforced and undermined by private actors, hacker armies, corporate "hack-backs", for profit cyber-security firms and consultancies (Harris 2014), so that the "military industrial" complex's of national security states become more and more interfaced with criminal markets and "the dark web", and increasingly dependent by corporate collaborations, which can both enable and constrain state power (for example, the PRISM compliance between the NSA and giant info-corporations followed by "encryption" conflicts between FBI and Apple etc). Cyber-war thus becomes a domain beyond public oversight and democratic control.
Cyber-war is a new way of clandestine mobilization and disciplining of populations. The mass mobilizations of huge armies are thought of as past, but cyber-war offers both states and movements new forms of recruitment, beyond the professional armies, whether by induction into patriotic hacking, Anonymous-style scrip- hacking or jihadist virtual interpellation. By the same token it also sets in motion, through surveillance, a new militarized panopticism, capable of both highly personalized targeting of suspects (Duncan 2014) and the generalized repressive chilling of networks (Deibert 2013).
Cyber-war is increasingly automated, operating by malware implantation, bot -nets, chat bots, the tweaking of algorithmic filter- bubbles, big-data scanning surveillance and the "kill-chains" of drone-warfare (Deibert 2013; Cockburn 2015; Shaw 2016). It thus becomes a machinic capitalist unconscious, a subterranean process in which the participants are made unwittingly or at least unthinkingly complicit by their everyday involvement in a ubiquitously networked social context.
This subterranean militarized digital environment poses contemporary anti-capitalist movements with difficult dilemmas about how, when or if to practice networked organization, whose speed and secrecy offer some powerful advantages, but also confound the slower processes of mundane organization and are intensely vulnerable to surveillance and cyber-crackdowns. Future Marxist revolutionaries, operating under conditions of surveillance and sous veillance, viral information and disinformation, encryption and encryption-breaking, anonymization, verification, authentication, and algorithmic digital war, will have to make constant strategic and tactical decisions about whether to adopt cyber-war techniques. The resort to cyber-war by state actors, their proxies, and their terrorist opponents means that opposition to militarization of the digital is an important arena of organization, mobilizing popular sentiment against the enlarged scope of state and corporate mass surveillance, viral propaganda, covert malware operations, and, more broadly pressing against the aggressive disorders of the world market. Paradoxically, however, as Snowden, Wikileaks and Anonymous have shown, revealing the scope of the destruction, actual and potential, inflicted by global capitalism's new wave of wars and cyber-wars itself requires hacker ingenuity. Therefore the best current revolutionary strategy may be the paradoxical one of (to renew another phrase from the archive of the left) "Krieg dem Krieg", "war on war" (Nation 2009, or in this case, "cyber-war on cyber-war".