Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm fails – ensures an uncoordinated bifurcated system that undermines deterrence and causes miscal

Bergmann and Schmitt 21 (Max Bergmann, Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress, focusing on European security and US-Russia relations. Alexandra Schmitt, Senior Policy Analyst, “It’s time to get the Pentagon out of the business of administering U.S. foreign aid,” Washington Post, March 11, 2021, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/11/its-time-get-pentagon-out-business-administering-us-foreign-aid/, WC)

The result today is that the United States has two distinct security assistance systems — one at the State Department and one at the Defense Department — doing the same thing. That has created a bureaucratic mess involving countless planning and operational conflicts — one that also makes it impossible for Congress to conduct effective oversight, since the two departments answer to different committees. Recognizing the problem, some policymakers in Congress and the Pentagon have recently implemented a few useful reforms — but they go only so far.

Today, when combatant commanders show up in the countries they’re assigned to, they frequently have security assistance funding at their disposal. But State Department officials of similar rank often lack comparably flexible funding and yet have to deliver tough messages on other U.S. foreign policy priorities, from human rights to economic reform, democratization or even climate policy. This power imbalance is not lost on foreign partners, and they act accordingly, often tuning out the State Department while cultivating their relations with the Defense Department.

The current bifurcated system is not just wasteful — it’s also potentially dangerous. Policymakers originally expanded Defense Department assistance in response to the post-9/11 focus on counterterrorism, when security assistance was often seen as a technical tool to smooth collaboration with foreign militaries. But in a new era of global great power competition, the provision of arms to another country sends a loud foreign policy signal, one that can easily lead to miscalculation. Those assistance decisions need to be well coordinated and calibrated by diplomats, not generals.

Fortunately, fixing this bureaucratic morass is straightforward: Just give the money to the State Department. Our new report argues that transferring the roughly $7 billion dollars in annual Defense Department security assistance funds that train and equip military partners to the State Department would restore the foreign aid system to its original conception as outlined in the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961. The law put the secretary of state in charge of supervising all foreign assistance, including “military assistance” — exactly the programs that the Defense Department is now running on its own.

Putting the State Department back in charge of security assistance will give it renewed clout and minimize needless waste and bureaucratic confusion. Most importantly, it will reaffirm our commitment to a foreign policy based on democratic values and support for human rights.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.