DoS solves – centralizing control of money ensures effective foreign assistance
Roberts 17 (James Roberts, Former Research Fellow For Economic Freedom and Growth at Heritage, “America Needs a Stronger State Department, Not an ‘Independent’ Foreign Aid Agency,” Heritage, Nov 17, 2017, https://www.heritage.org/defense/commentary/america-needs-stronger-state-department-not-independent-foreign-aid-agency)
But foreign assistance is increasingly a core State Department function. Money is critical in influencing people and governments around the world to achieve America’s short- and medium- term national security objectives.
Those who trumpet USAID’s independence and oppose its merger with the State Department basically are arguing that the United States should have two State Departments—one with money and one largely without. That may fulfill the desires of bureaucrats building their fiefdoms or foreign aid contractors that prefer to deal with one independent federal agency, but such a solution ill serves the country.
Just as is the case overseas, where the U.S. ambassador is the senior-most official in an American embassy, in Washington the secretary of state should have undisputed authority over decisions about allocating U.S. foreign assistance. The State Department—highly competent, well-equipped, appropriately staffed and resourced—should include a foreign assistance component. That is what countries such as Canada, Denmark, and Sweden already have done.