Perm shields the link and the CP links to DoD DA – their budgets are synchronized and DoD is essential to security assistance
Doubleday 17 (Justin Doubleday, managing editor of Inside the Pentagon until June 2021, where he focused on defense-wide topics including budgets, acquisition policy, combatant commands, missile defense and cyber, “DOD, State Department establish security assistance steering committee,” Inside the Pentagon , September 28, 2017, Vol. 33, No. 39, pp. 1, 10-11, WC)
The Pentagon and the State Department have set up a high-level group to help synchronize the two agencies’ control over billions of dollars’ worth of security assistance to foreign countries.
The Security Sector Assistance Steering Group was established this past spring by Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, according to Todd Harvey, acting assistant secretary of defense for strategy, plans and capabilities. Harvey testified before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee Sept. 26.
The steering committee will help “oversee a collaborative planning process, identifying top national security priorities and synchronizing investments to maximize results,” according to Harvey’s written testimony.
One of the committee’s immediate priorities is to develop a process for fiscal year 2018 security sector assistance planning to “permit State and DOD to validate security assistance requirements for countries that directly support this administration’s top priorities,” according to Tina Kaidanow, acting assistant secretary of state for the bureau of political military affairs. Kaidanow and Harvey are co-chairs of the new steering committee.
The committee will also ensure DOD’s expanding security assistance programs match up with the State Department’s traditional lead role for that function, according to Kaidanow’s testimony. The State Department requested $5.1 billion for Foreign Military Financing in FY-18, with $3.1 billion earmarked for Israel and $1.3 billion planned for Egypt.
But Senate Foreign Relations Committee Ranking Member Ben Cardin (D-MD) expressed concern over the growing security assistance role played by the Pentagon. DOD oversees several security assistance programs, including the $1.5 billion Counter-Islamic State of Iraq and Syria fund and the $4.2 billion Afghanistan Security Forces Fund.
Cardin called such programs “necessary and important,” but worried about the control over security assistance shifting from the State Department to the Pentagon.
“My chief concern, however, is that DOD is setting up an essentially parallel security assistance structure without sufficient State Department oversight, input and coordination,” Cardin said. “Combine this with the current administration’s profoundly unwise proposal to slash the Department of State’s budget, opaque reorganization efforts and increasing loss of experienced personnel, and one could easily see us in a scenario in which the Department of Defense could become the dominant source of U.S. security assistance.”
Cardin pointed to section 333 of Title 10, which mandates the secretary of state concur with any train-and-equip program proposed by the Pentagon.
The new steering committee will “optimize section 333 military assistance and [Foreign Military Financing] resources to effectively advance national security objectives, leverage each Department’s expertise and authorities, and reinforce our respective requests to Congress,” according to Kaidanow’s testimony.
“In the longer term, the intent is to strategically integrate State and DOD planning and resourcing processes for a wider range of SSA resources, including by synchronizing budget requests and rationalizing and refining the use of SSA authorities,” her testimony added. -- Justin Doubleday