Abandonment/unilateralism Wrecks US hegemony – removes network of diplomatic and military capabilities and forecloses agenda-setting power to new regional blocs
Kaufmann, Hertie School of Governance; Laius, Postdoctorate at Otto Suhr Institute; 17 (Sonja, Mathis, “Ever closer or lost at sea? Scenarios for the future of transatlantic relations,” https://www-sciencedirect-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/science/article/pii/S0016328716303615)//EF
The decline of American hegemony has been proclaimed many times, but the US has continued to be the sole superpower on the block. Yet the 2016 election might go down in history as the turning point – if the new administration follows through with its plan to put ‘America First’ and withdraws from international responsibilities. This policy change puts European collective action capacity to a test, leaving the EU to carry on the torch of liberal values and democracy in the global world order. Following the Brexit shock, EU leaders agree on a communications and legitimacy offensive to fend off populist movements in the wake of Brexit. Europe’s foreign policy apparatus evolves. As the EEAS gains experience and fine-tunes its working relationship with member states and the EU Commission, the changes intended by the Lisbon treaty begin to materialize in practical terms. The center of gravity for day-to-day foreign policy moves to the European level, not least because EU mxembers are happy to consolidate expensive foreign operations. At the same time, the United States decrease their footprint in terms of both diplomatic and military capabilities abroad. US foreign policy focuses on core regions and tasks, which means cutting back on large-scale diplomatic initiatives, early warning and conflict resolution, or intelligence analysis. These policy shifts draw heavy criticism from European allies and the transatlantic relationship suffers − also because the new US administration uses a different tone and style towards the old allies. These organizational and strategic changes are reflected in policy choices. In United Nations negotiations on climate change, the EU is the only actor that comes close to China’s willingness and capacity for leadership. Participants in transatlantic working groups discover that their goals are not aligned. In addition, US negotiators are much less enthusiastic about investing political capital and resources in global governance. UN operational budgets across the board are sharply reduced reflecting a reduction in US contributions that cannot be compensated by others. Thus, while the UN remains a forum for deliberation, its agencies lose practical relevance in global governance. At the same time, the member states of the European Union come to terms with the fact that their transatlantic partner seems less willing to assume a leadership role. A number of governments and the foreign-policy institutions in Brussels take on more responsibility in regional and global affairs. As a result, EU policymakers focus more heavily on inter-regional cooperation with organizations from Africa, Latin America and Asia. A number of so-called ‘intensive partnership’ treaties with regional blocs and individual emerging powers address cross-border issues, such as migration and the fight against crime. In trade and investment, regional arrangements increasingly replace the WTO, which is in hibernation due to the United States’ refusal to champion further trade liberalization on a global scale. NATO suffers from funding cuts and is strictly limited to its core mandate for territorial defense, while the UN Security Council drops from gridlock to paralysis. Military interventions still take place – but only based on ad-hoc coalitions. For the EU this means creating a more deeply integrated but still voluntary defense framework with a focus on security in the near abroad and African countries of strategic interest. A first indicator for this scenario is a shift in US foreign policy from a global leadership role to a few selected initiatives. American agenda-setting power on the global stage is reduced as foreign-policy priorities change, but also because European allies in turn focus on other partners and opportunities. EU-internal changes in the institutional setup and practice of foreign policy are another indicator to consider. The clearest sign of this scenario, however, would be bolder and more controversial European actions on the global arena – both diplomatically and militarily.