NATO backsliding risks existential threats
Berzina 21 Kristine Berzina, senior fellow and head of the geopolitics team at the Alliance for Securing Democracy, MA international relations, University of Cambridge, BA political science and history, Yale University, “Democratic Resilience and Cooperation at the Core of NATO’s Future,” testimony before the NATO Parliamentary Assembly, November 2021, https://www.nato-pa.int/sites/default/files/2021-11/2021%20-%20TESTIMONY%20ON%20DEMOCRATIC%20RESILIENCE%20AND%20COOPERATION%20AT%20THE%20CORE%20OF%20NATO.docx /GoGreen!
NATO is at a critical moment of re-invention. The alliance survived the tumultuous years of the Trump presidency – in practice, U.S. commitments to collective defense remained strong, and defense spending across the alliance has been growing every year since 2015. The next question is how the alliance can not only survive but thrive. NATO will need evolve to adapt to an ever-increasing array of threats, from disruptive technologies to renewed great power competition with China and Russia. And because adversaries target not only NATO’s borders but strike society within NATO countries, the alliance will need to give more attention to defending against threats at home. Improving NATO’s resilience needs to go beyond shoring up critical infrastructure and cyber capacity to bolstering the democratic principles and systems that underpin the alliance.
The North Atlantic Treaty that set up NATO in 1949 explicitly recognizes the NATO allies’ determination to “safeguard the freedom, common heritage and civilization of their peoples, founded on the principles of democracy, individual liberty and the rule of law.” My colleagues and I at the Alliance for Securing Democracy called on NATO to uphold these values within the Alliance and with partner countries in a policy blueprint for countering authoritarian interference in Europe.
Establishing a Center for Democratic Resilience at NATO would be one way to achieve the goal of safeguarding democracy and upholding the values on which the alliance was founded. The exact structure of a NATO body focusing on democratic resilience can vary, yet the need to address both external and internal threats to democracy is paramount.
Democracy: Not outside the scope of NATO
Democracy does not go beyond the scope of NATO. The alliance’s founding treaty foresees NATO not only as a body for collective defense but also for political consultation. And this provision would allow NATO members to draw on each other for support and guidance on countering threats to their democratic processes and institutions.
NATO exists to help its members protect themselves and assist each other in countering existential threats – those against territorial integrity as well as political independence. Article Five’s collective defense provisions against armed attack are well known. But Article Four of the Washington Treaty calls on members to “consult together whenever, in the opinion of any of them, the territorial integrity, political independence or security of any of the Parties is threatened.”
Russia and other authoritarian states seek to undermine democratic and electoral processes in NATO countries through cyber attacks, disinformation campaigns, economic coercion, among other tactics. These asymmetric efforts can erode the political independence of NATO states, undermine their sovereignty, and if successful, alter the direction of NATO policy. This is at the heart of the question of political independence for individual allies and NATO as a whole.
The need to counter threats to democracy is growing. The Alliance for Securing Democracy’s Authoritarian Interference Tracker logs 600 instances in which Russia or China have sought to undermine democracy across forty NATO and non-NATO democracies in North America and Europe. Russia began using many of these tools, from economic coercion to information manipulation, in the Soviet era. But in recent years, other autocratic states including China are learning from Russia’s example. In the Covid-19 pandemic, China has increasingly piggybacked off Russia’s information network and imitating its tactics.
Being vocal about the values of democracy, liberty, and the rule of law matters in and of itself. If these values were put forward more prominently at the alliance, as a Center for Democratic Resilience could do, NATO members would feel more accountable on the question of values and democratic health to their fellow allies. Expectations on good governance should be made clear in routine NATO operations. Moreover, focusing on these values may allow NATO countries to build confidence and support for democratic systems at home.
Not only external threats
The external dimension of threats against democracy may be fairly straight-forward to address at NATO. Allies could come together, ideally in a regular manner such as that which would be provided by a Center for Democratic Resilience, to assess and provide solutions for minimizing threats. But if NATO is to counter the threats posed by Russia, and increasingly, China, it will have to address vulnerabilities within European societies – how countries choose partners for technological innovation, trade, and infrastructure projects as well. These are the vulnerabilities that allow economic coercion, cyber-attacks, and information manipulation to take hold.
A difficulty for NATO will be to address internal issues in member states. But NATO will need to find a way to address domestic threats to democracy. Extremist groups within NATO societies are now taking up the tactics started by Moscow, from information manipulation to cyber-attacks. Political leaders in NATO members have taken steps to restrict democratic freedoms in their countries. A NATO node for democratic resilience could work in cooperation with civil society and other international organizations to address these more sensitive domestic issues.