Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Extinction

Haque 22 Umair Haque, economist, former director of the Havas Media Lab, degrees from London Business School and McGill University, “We’re Becoming a Far-Right Planet,” Eudaimonia and Co, 4-15-2022, https://eand.co/were-becoming-a-far-right-planet-dc0487fa3b45 /GoGreen!

If It Feels Like the 1930’s Are Repeating Themselves — Only With Nukes — That’s Because They Are

There are two ways to think about the Russia’s bloody and brutal and criminal war in Ukraine. One is that Putin is a madman — with nukes. The second is even more chilling. It’s that Putin himself is a mere symptom, of deeper forces. These forces are vast and impersonal — just forces of history, like great currents beneath the waves of oceans. What do I mean? This second way to think — and the more that I reflect on it, the more accurate way, perhaps — goes like this.

We have many, many Big Existential Threats as a world. Climate change, mass extinction, ecological collapse, then pandemics, now nuclear war. But underlying all of these — and unifying them — is a deeply disturbing political reality. Over the last decade or two, the planet has swung so far right that it might as well have tilted on its axis. We are beginning to live on a far right planet.

And what kind of life, civilization, future is really possible on a far right planet? Not a democratic one. Not a peaceful one. It looks a lot like….this one. War, chaos, hate, rage.

This is a sea change. We haven’t lived on a far right planet for a long time. The last time we had hints of such a thing was in the 1930s. What’s happening today may be even more troubling, though, because it’s more widespread. I don’t think modern history — or even semi-modern history — has seen the entire planet swing far right so fast and hard that the globe is juddering in fear and agony.

Let me give you several examples of what I mean — and then I want to discuss why this is happening. We’ll start with rich countries — who are the obvious ones.

In America, it’s true, that Joe Biden’s President — but it’s truer that half the country or more is in open revolt against not just him, but the idea of liberal democracy. To teach kids that gay people exist is now a crime. Women’s rights are being taken away. Minorities are openly scapegoated. Yet another Black man was just shot in the head by a police officer…for nothing…on video. And shortly, every indication is that America’s conservatives are going to sweep into power, and reduce democracy to a shell, having laid the groundwork to snatch the election by whatever means necessary, from perverting electoral mechanisms, to another coup.

America’s new wave of laws attacking women and minorities and even teachers — tip lines, informants, secret polices — have roots in the Fugitive Slave Act, which deputised anyone to be a vigilante, and inspired the Nazis. That is how regressive its right wing revolt really is. America is therefore already ranked as a flawed democracy.

Take another set of rich Western countries, though. Britain’s head of state is literally now found to have broken the law. He didn’t resign. Instead, he came up with a plan to ship…refugees…to Rwanda…which is an authoritarian, totalitarian state whose record on human rights abuses is abysmal…and all that’s flagrantly against the law…again. None of this is remotely compatible with liberal democracy — from the rule of law to equality to justice to truth.

Then there’s Australia. Australians, deeply nationalistic people, think proudly of themselves as a liberal democracy, and fly into a rage when you criticise their nation. Yet the truth is their PM is a climate change denier, they pioneered the idea of human trafficking refugees to other countries — breaking international law — they have the highest per capita carbon emissions on the planet, and none of this seems to matter at all to them very much. Like Britain, for all intents and purposes, Australia is heading towards the far right. How else would you describe one whose PM denies climate change, while its ravaged by megafloods and storms and fires — and people just shrug?

In France, of course, Marine Le Pen is within striking distance of the Presidency. She comes from a family of proto-Nazi sympathizers, and openly backs Putin. Elected, she’d shred the West. She’s already called for NATO to effectively be broken up, and Frexit to happen. The EU would no longer exist as we know it. France is right on the brink of joining America, Australia, and Britain in hurtling towards far right politics.

Now, the rejoinder to all this will be: “At least we’re not Rwanda!!” But that isn’t the test of a liberal democracy. It’s whether, obviously, a nation is living up to the ideals of a democracy. Whether it values freedom, equality, truth, justice, decency, the rule of law, and so forth. It’s all too easy to see that in the cases I’ve presented to you, these things now have little value. When your head of state denies climate change — truth? LOL. When he breaks the law and covers it up by breaking the law — justice? LOL. When a society has tip lines to inform on neighbours for the crime of reading banned books — equality? Freedom? LOL.

This phenomenon stretches right around the world. It’s not just the rich world, the West, turning so far right that Adolf Hitler’s grinning approvingly, it’s also, obviously, the rest of it. Just two short decades ago, there were high hopes that Russia would evolve into a mature, stable, healthy democracy. Instead, it imploded into Putinism — and war. The same, more or less, is true in China and India. Across Asia and Africa and Europe, too. The planet is turning far right.

This is a scary thing. It has never really happened before. Yes, really, never.

Political scientists, scratching their heads, began to call this phenomenon “democratic backsliding.” But that turn of phrase is inaccurate. It implies that democracy is failing from both sides, left and right. We don’t live in an age, though, where the far left is overthrowing legitimately elected democracies. We live in one where the far right is. “Democratic backsliding” is therefore another way, really, to say — not say, in fact — “we are beginning to live on a far right planet.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.