Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Best studies prove short-termism, truth decay, and weak multilateralism are NOT inherent to democracy, but to backsliding – and democracy’s net better at overcoming collective action problems

Lindvall 21 Daniel Lindvall, researcher at the Climate Change Leadership Initiative at the Department of Earth Sciences in Uppsala University, PhD sociology, “Democracy and the Challenge of Climate Change,” International IDEA Discussion Paper 3/2021, International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, 2021, https://www.idea.int/sites/default/files/publications/democracy-and-the-challenge-of-the-climate-change.pdf /GoGreen!

Although democracies do better on average than authoritarian systems, climate change is an issue that poses specific challenges to the governing capacity of democracy. The challenge of climate change is complex and has sometimes been described as a ‘wicked problem’. It is an issue in the interface between natural and human systems, and therefore it affects all spheres of life, but in unpredictable ways. The complexity of climate change is one of the prime reasons why democracies have failed to deal adequately with the crisis. The climate crisis is moreover a global challenge, and democracies have not sufficiently managed to act beyond the constraints of the national states. The short-term focus of most democratic decision-making has been an additional weakness. Democracy is a system limited by time and space, while the problem of climate change runs across generations and national borders. Moreover, the influence of fossil fuel lobbyism, corruption, policy capture and weak institutional capacity have hampered democracies from acting responsibly.

As this paper demonstrates, democracies nevertheless possess several advantages when it comes to tackling the climate crisis. Governing systems that allow civil participation, a free flow of information and processes of assessment and evaluation seem to be more capable than authoritarian regimes in dealing with issues of great complexity. Studies on climate change cooperation have also shown that, in general, democracies are more active in international negotiations and more likely to keep their political commitments. The international cooperation on climate change relies to a great extent on open and democratic societies, providing a base for journalists and civil society organizations covering and reporting on the negotiations and monitoring compliance. Moreover, technological innovation, particularly on renewable energy, has made the solutions to the climate crisis less cross-border intensive and extensive, motivating both individual countries, regions and cities, and companies, communities and individuals, to act on their own. Active engagement by individuals and civil society organizations can create pressure for strong policy responses on a local, national and global level.

Studies also show that democracies are improving their performance on long-term policies—for instance, on climate action and on the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Institutional changes, such as the adoption of climate legislation and advisory bodies, and activities within democracies, such as the youth-driven climate movement and processes of climate litigation, have made them even less vulnerable to short-termism. Despite this, democracies are still not delivering on their climate pledges. In many fragile democracies, corruption is obstructing the policymaking process on climate and preventing adequate and efficient implementation. The fossil fuel industry still wields substantial influence on politics in several democratic countries. In this respect, the lack of trustworthy and independent public institutions, with the ability to counteract policy capture and corruption, protect human rights, and deliver on the principles of the rule of law and good governance, is a serious barrier on the path towards a sustainable future.

In conclusion, functioning democracy is essential to effectively deal with the climate crisis; however, as long as many democracies are suffering from their own institutional failures, they will not be able deliver adequately. Consequently, efforts to develop and support democracy around the world need to be sustained, but it is also necessary to undertake certain measures, activities and reforms to make democracy more able to tackle the climate crisis. The policy advice in this paper focuses on the necessity to overcome short-termism, ensure citizen participation, act on climate injustice, develop knowledge-based decision-making and strengthen the state capacity. Further research on the nexus of democracy and climate is also needed, to better understand both the effects climate change could have on democracy as such and how democratic governance could be developed to become more capable of dealing with the crisis at hand.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.