The plan devastates ability to leverage SC for democracy gains
Mehta 17 Aaron Mehta, Senior Pentagon Correspondent and Associate Editor for Defense News, graduate of Tufts University, “Standoff Brews Over the Future of US Security Assistance,” Defense News, 3-28-2017, https://www.defensenews.com/2017/03/28/standoff-brews-over-the-future-of-us-security-assistance/ /GoGreen!
One central argument of State’s advocates is that DoD’s parallel security-assistance apparatus undermines statecraft. By creating a second track where nations can go to get American military goods, ambassadors in the field are robbed of key carrots and sticks when pushing on issues such as human rights.
For example, in 2015, Kenya received $48.2 million in funding for 1206 counterterrorism train-and-equip missions, according to figures compiled by Security Assistance Monitor. That same year, a State Department human rights report cited Kenya’s "security force abuses, including alleged unlawful killings, forced disappearances, torture, and use of excessive force; interethnic violence; and widespread corruption and impunity."
"Talk to the military guys coming back from Africa or Asia and they say, ‘We’re just running the mission, we don’t worry about diplomatic aspects or the relationships being formulated, we’re building mil-to-mil bridges,'" Stohl said. "It’s an important relationship, one that should be cultivated, but it is not separate from the diplomatic and foreign policy relationships that have to be developed and take time. If you lose the foreign policy piece and just focus on the security piece, you’re doing a disservice to the larger strategic objectives."
US Marine and Romanian military officials pose together after the culminating event of Platinum Eagle aboard Smardan Training Area, Romania, May 15. Platinum Eagle is a multi-national exercise designed to build partner capacity and interoperability between the US and NATO Allies. (Photo: Cpl. Kelly L. Street/US Marine Corps)
Streamlining Authorities
The Senate-passed bill would collapse the collection of security-cooperation authorities from Title 10 and elsewhere into a single chapter of US law. It also repeals the Pentagon’s many "train-and-equip" policies and rolls them into a single authority.
It consolidates more than $2 billion in security-cooperating funding into a new Security Cooperation Enhancement Fund, a balm to senior DoD officials who were scraping dollars together from various accounts. In return, the defense secretary must submit an annual budget justification, report on the effectiveness of its efforts, and take responsibility for management oversight.
While the bill doesn’t give the Pentagon new authorities, it allows more flexibility within the framework, said Rand Senior Analyst Michael McNerney. While that has sparked fears at the State Department that the bill would grant DoD with a slush fund, McNerney said that appears to be balanced with greater congressional oversight.
"I think they felt it was a worthwhile tradeoff to give the Pentagon more flexibility if they can start showing their work," McNerney said of the bill.
"Building security capabilities of a partner nation through security cooperation requires a specialized set of skills, and the current system neither develops those skills among its workforce nor rationally assigns its workforce to match appropriate skills with requirements," a bill summary reads.
Those who crafted the bill say it was drafted to comply with a 2013 White House directive on security assistance, Presidential Policy Directive 23, which is meant to define the security cooperation status quo for the State Department and the Pentagon.
"The Senate NDAA was deliberately designed to be consistent with that directive, which maintained the State Department’s primacy on foreign policy and security-sector assistance, but also acknowledged DoD has an important role in security-sector assistance," Walker said. "We worked hard to thread that needle."
In the patchwork of authorities, some DoD security cooperation programs gave State concurrence authority while others mandated "joint-formulation" programs, meaning State and DoD would plan programs together from inception. In the Senate’s consolidation plans, State would gain concurrence but lose "joint formulation" rights.
According to Walker, the two sides need to come together on a process to plan and prioritize together.
"Everyone recognizes that there have been shortcomings on both sides in planning and prioritizing integrated security-cooperation efforts," Walker said. "Congress has to continue to work with DoD and State to ensure we achieve the unity of effort we all seek."
Pro-State government officials, speaking on background, were not as conciliatory. The new legislative action, they fear, would spell the end of a meaningful role for State because DoD’s structure would legitimize a separate foreign-assistance avenue controlled by the military. And because the military tends to beat diplomacy in budget fights, the system would by default tilt toward the Pentagon, the thinking goes.
And those backing State fear that losing the ability to attach human-rights and geopolitical concerns to weapon sales or training will blow up in the face of the US government. They point out how arming a nation like the Philippines to counter China, with a focus solely on the military results and not the greater political picture, could end up with a US-backed nation striking against the larger Pacific country.
"I’d rather have a system that is duplicative and wasteful than see it all go under the Pentagon," said one US government official. "At some point, doing so will cause a huge [geopolitical] problem."
Congressional Action
It’s unclear how much traction State’s concerns will have in Congress. Crucially, the White House mentioned the matter in its policy statement on the Senate’s NDAA but stopped short of threatening a veto over it.
State does have allies. The Senate Appropriations State and Foreign Operations and Related Programs Subcommittee — chaired by Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C. — pushed back against the NDAA language in its appropriations bill, approved by the panel on June 29.
It cites existing law to assert "the primacy of the Secretary of State in the conduct of foreign affairs," pushing to enshrine the secretary’s "responsibility for the continuous supervision and general direction" of economic, law-enforcement, justice-sector and military assistance, to include military training programs.
The report blames the National Security Council, under President Obama and previous administrations, for failing to coordinate relevant policies for better cooperation. That, combined with ad-hoc responses to recent crises, "created parallel and competing foreign-assistance programs, particularly at the Department of Defense," the report said.
When these programs are allowed proceed outside "a whole-of-government" approach under the direction of the president and the secretary of state, it "erodes the coherent, coordinated, and effective implementation of U.S. foreign policy," the report warned.