No trade-off – bilats do NOT snowball, they’re continually calibrated to optimize complementarity – AND current bilats thump or disprove
Hindrén 22 Rasmus Hindrén, Head of International Relations at the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats and senior non-resident fellow at the Atlantic Council, “What Finland will bring to NATO – and how it might change the alliance,” Breaking Defense, 5-19-2022, https://breakingdefense.com/2022/05/what-finland-will-bring-to-nato-and-how-it-might-change-the-alliance/ /GoGreen!
Other defense cooperation structures, like JEF and strategic bilateral partnerships can support interoperability and developing new capabilities, but they might also offer flexible mechanisms for responding to crises where NATO as a whole would be unwilling or unable to act. On the other hand, there might be pressure to downscale some of the other elements of defense cooperation in the fear that they would be too duplicative or forcing Finland to spread its efforts too thin. In the end, Finland would calibrate its network of defense cooperation in the way that adds most value.
One area where bilateral cooperation will not drop off, however, is very clear. Every country in NATO cherishes their bilateral defense cooperation with the US and Finland would not be an exception. Finland would want to continue and deepen that bilateral cooperation, while understanding the longer-term trends of strategic competition will force the United States to focus its gaze more on the Indo-Pacific region.
When it comes to multilateral decision-making, as a general rule Finland avoids situations where it is politically isolated or even in a small minority. In multilateral fora that often means a forceful support to an emerging consensus. In substance terms, this would likely include underlining the role of the transatlantic relationship but balancing it with a regional and European approach.
Another natural path would be to focus heavily on cooperation with neighboring countries like Norway and, naturally, Sweden; in fact, with all five Nordic nations in the alliance, a greater NATO focus on the high north would seem likely to emerge.
Multilateralism is likely to stick: Two key strands of Finnish security and defense policy would likely be continued in NATO: a focus on bilateral and minilateral defense cooperation mechanisms and support to the EU’s evolving security and defense policy.
Although it was hesitant until the around the time of the ratification of the Lisbon treaty, Finland has been a strong proponent of the EU defense policy ever since. This has been partially motivated by Finland being outside NATO but, more importantly, by the understanding that the EU is a broad security community with a sizeable toolbox of policies and capabilities. There are longstanding tensions between the EU and NATO on defense issues; as the newest alliance members, and hence high-profile, it is possible Sweden and Finland could play a role in bridging that gap.