BUT, even if they’re right, fragmentation is net better for interoperability in their impact scenarios
Hura 2K Myron Hura, Gary McLeod, Eric Laron, James Schneider, Daniel Gonzales, Dan Norton, Jody Jacobs, Kevin O’Connell, William Little, Richard Mesic, Lewis Jamison, RAND Project Air Force, “Interoperability: A Continuing Challenge in Coalition Air Operations,” 2000, https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1235/RAND_MR1235.pdf /GoGreen!
Although participation in coalition operations has varied greatly from situation to situation and over time (see Table A.4), a number of allies have been particularly reliable in their participation in recent coalitions in which the United States has also participated.
As shown in Table A.4, the most frequent NATO coalition partners in the 40 operations examined were the United Kingdom (29 of 40 operations), France (28), Turkey (23), Germany (22), and Italy and the Netherlands (21 each). Other NATO allies participated in fewer actions with the United States.
[Table A.2 OMITTED]
The implications are twofold. The first is that interoperability planning must be adaptive enough to accommodate the possibility of coalitions of different sizes and composed of different coalition partners. “Plug-and-play” is a concept that is well known at the technological level. But it is also required at the national level to provide for the possibility of different combinations of coalition partners; to manage the comings and goings of coalition members as the mission focus changes and/or missions are added, completed, or abandoned; and to minimize disruptions to the overall coalition effort. This suggests a focus on long-term interoperability solutions, including organizations, doctrine, procedures, and system architectures that can accommodate the dynamic character of coalitions, including transitions.
[Table A.3 OMITTED]
The second implication is that because the United States’ NATO allies vary in their coalition participation with the United States, the United States might be able to achieve important interoperability through a series of bilateral rather than alliance-wide efforts.