Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Counterplan tanks public support for NATO – key to sustain U.S. membership

Skidmore 12 David Skidmore, Drake University, “The Obama Presidency and US Foreign Policy: Where’s the Multilateralism?” International Studies Perspectives, no.13, 2012, pp.43-64, DOI 10.1111/j.1528-3585.2011.00454.x /GoGreen!

Policymakers tend to assume that foreign aid can attract public support only to the extent that it is perceived to serve narrowly focused national interests. Yet, the 1995 survey found that humanitarian rationales for aid attracted the strongest support. Americans were less inclined to favor aid programs designed to reward friendly countries or to win economic benefits for US business. Military aid was also quite unpopular. But majorities ranging from 74% to 91% wanted to maintain or increase aid devoted to ends such as child survival, humanitarian relief, repairing the environment, family planning, and long-term economic development. There existed strong support for targeting aid toward the poorest countries. Americans were skeptical, however, that aid actually reaches those who need it or achieves humanitarian aims. Roughly 80% of respondents believed that too much aid went to undemocratic regimes, that aid is plagued by waste and corruption, and that foreign assistance programs often foster dependence on the part of recipients.11

One obvious implication of these findings is that advocates for increased foreign aid would do well to correct public misperceptions that the United States is bearing a disproportionate burden as compared with other aid-giving countries. Yet, research conducted by the Aspen Institute suggests that the problem is more complicated: ‘‘When informants were confronted with such information, they showed momentary surprise, and then reverted to their old patterns of reasoning. A core rule of strategic frame analysis is at play here: if the facts don’t fit the frame, it is the facts that are rejected, not the frame’’ (Bales 2001:8).

A better strategy for mobilizing public support for aid is to emphasize America’s shared responsibility to respond to human suffering in concert with others. This approach shifts the focus from interests to values and assures members of the public that the burden is not borne by the United States alone. Funneling increasing proportions of US aid through bilateral rather than multilateral mechanisms actually undercuts the appeal of aid by reinforcing erroneous perceptions that America is on its own when it comes to fighting hunger, disease, and natural disasters. Placing aid within a multilateral context, by contrast, highlights the contributions of other states. A 2010 Chicago Council on Global Affairs survey found that only 8% supported the view that the United States should continue to serve as the pre-eminent leader in responding to international problems. On the other hand, only 19% felt that the United States should withdraw from efforts to solve most international problems. Instead, a large majority—71%—adopted the view that the United States should do its share in cooperation with other countries.

More generally, public support for multilateral engagement rises when the domestic audience is primed through exposure to cooperative frames. Framing involves the use of metaphors, analogies, and symbols that serve to cue up desired associations among audience members with respect to a given issue. Research conducted by the Aspen Institute has found that, in comparisons with a control group, respondent attitudes toward multilateral engagement abroad shifted in a positive direction when previously exposed to statements stressing interdependence, partnership, and shared norms among states and societies. This research also suggested that policymakers must convince members of the public that global problems are not intractable but instead amenable to feasible solutions.

Despite recent survey results pointing to declining support for international engagement, the challenge for policymakers who seek to overcome domestic obstacles to international engagement is less to expand the breadth of public support for such initiatives than to deepen the salience of multilateralism among members of the public. Passive and shallow majorities in favor of international cooperation do little to counter the influence of mobilized interests who oppose multilateral engagement or to overcome misperceptions among politicians who mistakenly read the public as unilateralist. A president seeking domestic support for a multilateral agenda in US foreign policy must therefore craft a compelling narrative that serves to awaken and mobilize the latent public support that has to date remained dormant and underutilized.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.