Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Counterplan’s signal of subregional fragmentation causes miscalc – escalates to global war

Richter 17 Wolfgang Richter, (Colonel ret.) Fellow at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs in Berlin, Research Group on Security Politics, “Return to Security Cooperation in Europe: The Stabilizing Role of Conventional Arms Control,” Deep Cuts Working Paper No.11, September 2017, https://deepcuts.org/images/PDF/DeepCuts_WP11_Richter.pdf /GoGreen!

No matter how one might assess sub-regional force balances, the assumption that an aggression against a NATO ally could be limited to a sub-regional war seems flawed. Nevertheless, a narrow focus on sub-regional Russian geographical advantages as to quick movements of land forces has been shaping the western discussion on military response options.

But launching a deliberate major aggression against an alliance that disposes at superior conventional forces and positive security guarantees by nuclear powers would entail incalculable risks of a global war. This is not a plausible scenario.

This is why the German government and western European allies during the Warsaw NATO Summit7 in July 2016 insisted that the purpose of an enhanced forward presence is a limited one: It aims at sending a strategic signal that the alliance cannot be divided rather than trying to engage in an arms race to win sub-regional military superiority. Consequently, they rejected requests to station several heavy brigades and to build-up new military frontlines in contradiction to the restraint commitment enshrined in the NATO-Russia Founding Act of 1997.8

The true core of the issue is that changing force postures and military doctrines, forward deployment of new units and the increase of military activities such as large scale manoeuvres, snap exercises without prior notification and near border reconnaissance flights are a matter of great concern, especially if accompanied by dangerous brinkmanship which can spin out of control. This concern is all the more relevant since a sense of a new confrontation is dominating political discourses in East and West and the narratives on the root causes of conflict have developed in opposite and incompatible directions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.