1. Proven Innovation Leadership — the combined capabilities of India, Israel, and the U.S. are sufficient to win the emerging tech race.
Patil 21 — Sameer Patil, Fellow at the International Security Studies Program at Gateway House—an Indian foreign policy think tank, former Assistant Director of the Joint Intelligence Committee at India's National Security Council Secretariat, holds a Ph.D. in International Politics from Jawaharlal Nehru University (India), 2021 (“Inserting India Into U.S.-Israel Defence Technology Cooperation,” Gateway House Paper Number 30, March, Available Online at https://www.gatewayhouse.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/DefTech_Doc-04.pdf, Accessed 07-14-2022, p. 15-23)
3. Capitalising on Defence Innovation and a Start-Up Ecosystem
Collaborating and building on defence innovation capabilities is key to achieving a long-term advantage in defence research and development. Therefore, to develop an India-Israel-U.S. defence technology partnership, the necessary starting point must be the existing defence innovation bases or start-up ecosystems in Israel and the U.S. These have provided the required technological capabilities to their respective militaries for years. India too has begun to harness the potential of the start-up ecosystem as part of its broader efforts to achieve self-reliance in defence.
In the U.S., compared with the initial technological innovation which originated in government-funded research facilities, today the locus has decisively shifted to the start-up ecosystem in Silicon Valley. This shift happened due to:
1. A decline in the defence R&D budget (from more than 1.2 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 1976, to 0.8 percent of GDP in 2019).38
2. Investment by the flourishing tech majors like Google and Amazon, in innovative technologies such as robotics and quantum computing.39
3. The enormous amount of venture capital investment in tech start-ups.40
The 2017 National Security Strategy acknowledged that the private sector had taken a lead over federal government agencies and underlined the need for the federal government to tap into these private capabilities.41 The Pentagon still spends a substantial amount of money on R&D as compared to many other industrialised economies—$59 billion as per the 2021 budget request.42 However, its pace of R&D and innovation is simply insufficient to maintain a lead over China, which not only stole technologies from the West but also consistently expanded investment in R&D over the last two decades and drafted its private sector into this effort. These investments have intensified under the “Made in China 2025” industrial strategy.44
One prime example of Silicon Valley’s lead in emerging technologies is quantum computing [end page 15] technology which can be applied to a variety of defence applications such as navigation, radar systems and sensing.45 Even as the U.S. plays catch-up up with China in quantum research, American tech giants IBM and Google have already achieved breakthroughs. In 2019, IBM unveiled Q System One, the first commercial quantum computer.46 This was followed by Google, which claimed quantum supremacy while unveiling Sycamore, its own quantum computer.47
The Pentagon has tried to tap into Silicon Valley innovations by setting up the Defense Innovation Unit (DIU, earlier known as DIUx). Headquartered in Mountain View, California, in the heart of the Valley, DIU works closely with the tech industry and start-ups to shortlist, fund and develop emerging technologies including AI, autonomous systems, cyber, space, human systems, and advanced energy and materials.48 A key obstacle for engaging start-ups in the defence sector is that start-ups view the defence establishment as bureaucratic and its acquisition procedures as cumbersome.
But by co-locating itself in the Silicon Valley and hiring staff from the tech and start-up community, the Pentagon has attempted to align itself with the vibrant start-up ecosystem and cut through traditional bureaucratic red tape to develop new technology and integrate it into the military.49
DIU has faced resistance from the risk-averse defence bureaucracy, but it promises to bring a change. For instance, working with partners from the Valley, the DIU developed and demonstrated a submarine-launched unmanned aerial system within a record time of eight months from the project’s commencement in May 2019.50 By September 2020, this system had already been deployed in the submarine fleet, something which typically takes years in the Department of Defense’s standard— often described as ‘antiquated’—acquisition procedure.51
Compared to the U.S., Israel takes a more organic approach to defence innovation, by synchronising the military, academia, defence industry, start-ups and investors. This has created a thriving defence innovation base centered around Tel Aviv and positioned Israel as a technologically advanced military power. [end page 16]
There are multiple factors undergirding Israel’s approach to defence innovation.
• Foremost is the Jewish perception of ‘siege mentality’ — a belief that the world is predisposed to behave negatively towards them. Since its creation, Israel has been surrounded by hostile neighbors, which has led to the ingrained belief, in Israel’s national and military leadership, that the only way to overcome this hostile strategic environment is by attaining a qualitative military edge over its adversaries.53
• Another factor is a “double feeding” phenomenon — whereby knowledge about the military’s technological requirements constantly circulates through the ecosystem due to conscription or compulsory military service. So, people who have served in the military become part of the tech industry, academia and start-up ecosystem, and are well aware of their military’s requirements.54
• Conscription also means that most of Israelis get an exposure to technology, either through the intelligence apparatus, coding or cyber security.55 This creates a valuable tech-savvy resource pool for the country’s technological-industrial ecosystem.
• Funding is also important: Israel has consistently topped the global charts for spending upwards of 4% of its GDP on R&D.56
These factors make Tel Aviv the second-best innovation base, after Silicon Valley, earning Israel the tag of “Start-up Nation”.57
Due to Israel’s geography, this ecosystem is close-knit with most of the critical actors being co-located. This ingrained advantage has been utilised by the Israeli Ministry of Defense’s Directorate of Defense Research & Development (also known as Maf’at), Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the industry and start-ups to apply emerging technologies for defence use. For instance, the Iron Dome system developed with U.S. assistance uses AI to analyse incoming missiles and determine if people are in danger.58 Likewise, the IDF has used AI to understand videos and read out the events taking place on the screen.59
The IAI too has sought to promote start-ups through an accelerator track, which encourages select start-ups to develop new technologies based on AI.60 [end page 17]
India has begun to look at start-ups as a way to equip its military with niche technology capabilities. Drawing from the U.S.’ DIU experience, India launched a Defence Innovation Organisation and Innovations in Defence Excellence (iDEX) program in 2017 to work with the R&D institutes, academia, industry, start-ups and individual innovators to create solutions to overcome the military’s technological shortcomings.61 Early technologies identified by iDEX for R&D include soldier protection systems, secure hardware encryption devices, GPS anti-jam devices, unmanned surface and underwater vehicles, and 4G/LTE tactical local area network, among others.62 According to the government, more than 300 start-ups are currently engaged by the iDEX program.63 To learn more from DIU experience on engaging start-ups, India and the U.S. have also agreed to assign Indian liaison officers to the DIU’s unit in Silicon Valley.64
There is an opportunity to take this one step forward by joining hands with Israel and the U.S. on emerging technologies. This potential collaboration must conjoin the three innovation hubs of Silicon Valley, Tel Aviv and Bengaluru to capitalise on their respective strengths and declared national technology priorities. As Table 2 shows, Bengaluru and Hyderabad, separated by roughly 550 kms., have a vibrant defence industrial base65 with multiple defence public sector units, the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) research establishments, private sector companies (including joint ventures with American and Israeli companies) and several start-ups in the defence and aerospace sector which are already contributing in various capacities to India’s defence and space needs. [end page 18]
[Several tables omitted — see URL; end pages 19-21]
As evident, Israel and the U.S. have already reached an advanced stage of research and cooperation for many of these technologies — compared to India which is still discussing the implications of some technologies like AI and quantum computing, and expanding its technological capabilities in others — such as robotics.82
These are disruptive technologies and will shape military doctrines and direct the nature of future warfare. A glimpse of this disruption was available during the fighting between Armenia and Azerbaijan in September-November 2020 over the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh territory. During the fighting, Azerbaijan deployed armed drones (purchased from Israel and Turkey) and smart weapons to inflict significant damage on Armenia, which relied on its air defences and tanks.83 [end page 22]
This example, along with similar experiences from the battlefields in Syria and Libya, demonstrates that “software-first” technologies like AI-enabled drones and robotics will play a decisive role in determining the outcomes of the wars of the future.84
This collaboration also offers opportunities for the Indian IT companies which have done coding for the Indian military, to play a major role. Companies such as Tata Consultancy Services, Wipro and HCL Technologies can help the Indian military better identify global technological trends and participate in defence innovation.
These technologies provide a good foundation for trilateral defence cooperation, which will give a technological edge to their respective militaries. Acquisition of these capabilities will particularly augment options for the Indian and American militaries in dealing with an aggressive China, which has adopted a hybrid warfare strategy against its adversaries.