Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

3. China Won’t Win The EDT Race — it’s too dependent on foreign innovation.

Frey and Osborne 20 — Carl Benedikt Frey, Oxford Martin Citi Fellow, Future of Work Director at the Oxford Martin School at Oxford University, author of The Technology Trap: Capital, Labor, and Power in the Age of Automation, Michael Osborne, Professor of Machine Learning at the University of Oxford, a Fellow at the Oxford Martin School, Co-Founder of Mind Foundry an organization which has a mission to enable Humans and AI to work together to solve the world’s most important problems, 2022 (“China Won’t Win the Race for AI Dominance,” Foreign Affairs, June 19th, Available Online at https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-06-19/china-wont-win-race-ai-dominance)

Decentralized experimentation and decision-making will likewise be critical if the world is to harness the benefits of artificial intelligence. China is at a disadvantage in this regard. The country’s recent surge in patent filings is often cited as evidence of its innovativeness, but simply counting patents isn’t a good way to measure innovation: studies show that ten percent of patents account for roughly 90 percent of total patent value, meaning that the vast majority are of little value. Patent citations offer a more useful indicator, and if we look at the 100 most cited patents since 2003, not a single one comes from China. Moreover, China’s leading artificial intelligence companies, including Tencent, Alibaba, and Baidu, are merely copies of Facebook, Amazon, and Google, tailored to the Chinese market.

As the late economic historian Alexander Gerschenkron observed, when a country lags behind the technological frontier, imitation and the adoption of foreign technology can take it a long way—and, in general, the further a country has fallen behind, the greater the role the state must play in driving industrial catch-up. Thanks to state investment in mass production technology, the Soviet Union grew rapidly during much of the Cold War, as did Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Indeed, numerous scholars have attributed the “Asian Miracle” to state-driven industrial catch-up. But while they were successful in closing some of the gap, these countries never managed to overtake the United States. Unlike imitation, which can be planned and coordinated, innovation is a voyage of exploration into the unknown, to paraphrase the economist and philosopher Friedrich von Hayek. And switching from imitation to innovation is hard: if it were easy, most countries would be innovating at the technological frontier.

By observing that China is unlikely to overtake the United States in technological innovation, we mean in no way to downplay China’s tremendous economic achievements since Deng Xiaoping came to power in 1978. China has plenty of talent, but the fact remains that, so far, Chinese innovation has mainly focused on incrementally improving technologies that were conceived elsewhere. Chinese companies currently lead the world in the development of 5G, for example, but their work builds on several previous generations of telecommunications technology. What Huawei demonstrates is that China has significant engineering capabilities, just like Japan and indeed the Soviet Union.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.