Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

E.U won’t follow on because of strategic autonomy

Binnendijk 22 — Hans Binnendijk, distinguished fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security, former Vice President for Research at the National Defense University at Johns Hopkins’ School of Advanced International Studies Director of the Institute for National Strategic Studies at Johns Hopkins’ School of Advanced International Studies, Daniel S. Hamilton, nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution’s Center on the United States and Europe, served as executive director of the American Consortium on European Union Studies, Alexander Vershbow, former Deputy Secretary General of NATO, former U.S ambassador to Russia, 2022 (“Strategic responsibility: Rebalancing European and trans-Atlantic defense,” Brookings Institute, June 24th, Available Online at https://www.brookings.edu/articles/strategic-responsibility-rebalancing-european-and-trans-atlantic-defense/)

The term “strategic autonomy,” popular in some European circles and anathema in others, stems originally from an earlier discourse within the French strategic community to describe France’s ambition to boost its military capabilities and reduce its dependencies so that it could act alone if necessary to protect French interests, beginning with crisis management operations in Africa and along Europe’s southern periphery. Of course, the European Union (EU) has been trying to develop its capacity for military action for some decades. Yet it was only in 2016 that the “strategic autonomy” term was lifted to the EU level, with the publication of the bloc’s Global Strategy. The document “nurtures the ambition of strategic autonomy for the European Union,” but does not define the notion’s content or its implications.[2]

In the years that followed, the term gained traction in some EU countries as concerns in Europe mounted about U.S. reliability as an ally under President Donald Trump, China’s rising technological and norm-setting challenges, and signs that the EU could be trampled as the American and Chinese elephants collided. Debate was further energized by signs of faltering European technological prowess, and especially by the COVID-19 pandemic, which exposed European dependencies across a number of health-related sectors.

Over time, the term began to assume a far more expansive meaning. European concerns have spawned a raft of related phrases, such as “European sovereignty,” “economic sovereignty,” “health sovereignty,” “technological sovereignty,” “data sovereignty,” “cybersecurity sovereignty,” even “digital strategic autonomy.” The result, as one European observer noted, is a “muddle of words.”

European commentators and leaders cloud things further by interpreting these assorted phrases very differently, according to their diverse strategic cultures, threat perceptions, and calculations of self-interest.

Taken together, however, this jumble conveys a shared and deeply-felt anxiety among many Europeans that their grand experiment of integration is being imperiled by internal weaknesses and external forces. In all of its forms, the autonomy narrative is meant to generate EU-wide consensus behind ambitious and often-costly initiatives to bolster the bloc’s technological, industrial, and norm-setting capabilities in ways that their proponents believe can preserve European competitiveness, lower strategic dependencies, raise the EU’s ability to resist geopolitical or geoeconomic coercion, and give it more freedom to maneuver and shape its environment.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.