Failure to share information makes Russia hybrid attacks successful
Beaulieu & Salvo 18 --- Brittany Beaulieu, fellow and program officer for GMF's Alliance for Securing Democracy, and David Salvo, deputy director of the Alliance for Securing Democracy (ASD) and a senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund, German Marshall Fund of the United States (2018), “NATO and Asymmetric Threats:: A Blueprint for Defense and Deterrence”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep18856.pdf
While NATO and the EU have pledged to improve their information sharing and coordination of responses across the asymmetric toolkit, these efforts are under-funded and lack high-level coordination. Moreover, the absence of a mechanism to share NATO classified information with the EU, an old problem, prevents both organizations from more systematic cooperation in responding jointly to the hybrid challenge. The lack of information sharing among allies at NATO is another challenge. For example, the United States did not share much information about the Russian operation against the 2016 presidential election as it unfolded and only a meager amount afterward. In the lead up to the French and German elections, information was shared on a bilateral basis, rather than through the NAC. The reservations of some allies to discuss their own vulnerabilities to interference operations only exacerbate NATO’s organizational impediments to addressing hybrid threats in a timely and coordinated manner. A formalized information sharing or early warning mechanism could help to rectify this problem, as would decisions in allied capitals to elevate discussion on hybrid threats at the NAC and share more threat information and intelligence.