Successful hybrid tactics crush democratic models and ensure global backsliding --- attribution and intelligence are key to deter
Wigell 21 --- Mikael Wigell, Research Director at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs, “Democratic Deterrence: How to Dissuade Hybrid Interference”, The Washington Quarterly Volume 44, 2021 - Issue 1, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0163660X.2021.1893027
Much of the debate on new “hybrid” threats has revolved around “little green men” and other grey zone military tactics, or hybrid warfare, essentially a military approach to conducting “indirect war” under special circumstances.4 The more pressing challenges from a Western perspective are the more subtle, non-military activities deployed by authoritarian regimes to penetrate democratic society. “Hybrid interference” is a concept developed to capture non-military practices for the mostly covert manipulation of other states’ strategic interests.5 As such, it bears resemblance to what was referred to as “active measures” during the Cold War and, more recently, in Russian strategic debate as gibridnaya voyna.
The idea of gibridnaya voyna is to avoid the traditional battlefield with the aim of destroying “the political cohesion of an adversary from the inside by employing a carefully crafted hybrid of non-military means and methods that amplify political, ideological, economic and other social polarisations within an adversary’s society, thus leading to its internal collapse.”6 While keeping diplomatic relations intact, and thus not breaking any official threshold of war, the aggressor mobilizes oppositionists and radicals within the target state through a host of means ranging from disinformation campaigns to corrupting political actors and financing subversive movements, carefully synchronized to compound the effect.
Hybrid interference avoids the use of overt kinetic means in order to maintain plausible deniability. Yet, it may include the use of targeted violence, through proxies, to inject fear and exploit emotional pressure points in the target society. In 2014, for example, pro-democracy protesters in Taiwan were attacked by some with links to the Chinese Communist Party to incite political tensions and undermine democratic governability.7 In Montenegro, Moscow instigated a coup attempt before the 2016 elections. The attempt involved harnessing its close relations to the Orthodox Church and the Serb minority population to foment distrust in the democratic process and, in the final phase, using Russian intelligence operatives disguising as police officers to create disruption by shooting protesters and blaming the Montenegrin government for killing innocents.8
Central to hybrid interference is subversion. Subversion refers to an aggressor state’s purposeful attempt to destabilize and undermine the authority of a target state by using local proxy actors.9 It specifically involves the use of disinformation and economic inducements to recruit and assist these actors inside the target country, detach their loyalties from the target government, and use them as interlocutors to transform the established social order and its structures of authority and norms. The aim is to weaken democratic governance and norms as a means of enhancing their own authoritarian standing. Not only are weakened democracies less able to directly confront these authoritarian aggressors, but they will also look less appealing as models of success and partners for others. By portraying Western democracies as corrupt and ungovernable, authoritarian regimes such as China, Iran, Russia, and Turkey are less at risk of being overthrown by their own populations.
As such, hybrid interference is designed as a flexible approach in which the tools and tactics can vary but will always be tailored to manipulate existing cleavages and sow internal dissension in target countries and alliances. Hybrid interference does not adopt a one-size-fits-all approach but exploits specific vulnerabilities depending on the context in the target country. The hybrid aggressor interferes in domestic politics by seeking to amplify divisions and hatred, undermining the “civic culture” that has been found to be so important for democratic governability by tempering the intensity of political conflicts and cleavages.10
The migrant crisis in Europe offered an excellent opportunity for authoritarian aggressors. By exposing rifts between “liberals” and “anti-liberals,” it allowed Russia and Turkey to leverage refugees as a disruptive force, fanning the already simmering political tensions in Europe. Following the outbreak of the Syrian civil war, Russia and Turkey began actively pushing migrants over the borders to Europe, while simultaneously engaging in disinformation campaigns by playing up rumored (or actual) misdeeds by immigrants and portraying European governments as unwilling or unable to manage the influx of people.11 To compound the polarizing effect, Russia also began channeling money to anti-immigrant and anti-EU political parties and movements such as France’s National Front.12 In this way, particularly Russia has contributed to Europe’s surge in anti-immigrant sentiments and populist support, as well as rising democratic dissatisfaction.13
Democratic Deterrence as a Novel Strategy
Western democracies urgently need to find counter measures against hybrid interference, recognizing that traditional military deterrence only works against predominantly military threats. By reducing clarity about who is doing what, or even whether somebody is actually doing anything, hybrid interference complicates traditional deterrence.14 Yet, the attribution problem is not insurmountable. The responsibility for interfering in US elections, for example, was traced and attributed to Russia, though only after a painstaking process involving much controversy and resources.15 But the question, then, even after the attribution problem is solved, becomes what to do about it? Any prudent deterrence posture needs to avoid unnecessary escalation, and a military response to political interference does not seem proportional.
The strategic concept of democratic deterrence suggests a novel way of thinking about deterrence to dissuade these hybrid interference activities by authoritarian states. Table 1 summarizes the differences between traditional military deterrence and democratic deterrence.
<Table Omitted>
First, in contrast to traditional deterrence that is state-based, democratic deterrence rests on a whole-of-society approach, albeit one in which the state retains a coordinating role. It harnesses market- and society-based actors in an effort to pull together resources and take full advantage of democracy’s societal strengths and cultural capital. This difference is important because in this new era of subversive politics, where the classical Westphalian dichotomy between internal and external state affairs has been blurred, deterrence is harder to achieve by state action alone. Deterring hybrid interference requires a whole-of-society response whereby various societal actors build resilience capacities, support the state in maintaining preparedness, and ensure the continuity of vital societal functions and supply lines. For instance, private actors often own full or partial stakes in critical infrastructure such as energy pipelines, undersea cables, railways, banking and finance, health services, and food supply. Ensuring that they live up to their responsibilities with regard to safety measures must form an essential part of any modern defense. The whole-of-society approach is thus an inclusive model of cooperation and joint preparedness that aims to bring all relevant actors together into a comprehensive system of deterrence. It involves an effort to diversify and devolve responsibilities for security production to market- and societal-based actors, while maintaining a strong coordinating role for the state.